Rochester has been a major league city before. It has not been one in a long time, and the distance between those two facts is the whole argument.
Bruce Blakeman, the Nassau County executive and Republican nominee for governor, has spent the fall telling Monroe County that the state is dead last in economic outlook and that upstate will not be treated as a branch office of the downstate budget. In Greece last month he made the turnout case: flip enough of Monroe and the math in a statewide race changes. Supporters around that argument have added a sharper one. If he wins, he should put a major league franchise on the table for Rochester, and he should let Rochester voters pick the league.
Not Buffalo. Buffalo already has the Bills and the Sabres. Not Brooklyn, where a separate group of supporters has been sketching a baseball bid around the old Dodger grievance. Rochester, the third-largest metropolitan economy in the state, the one that once had an NBA champion and still has the oldest continuous professional baseball operation in the country, and the one that has spent sixty years watching its teams leave or stay minor.
The proposal, as those supporters describe it, is simple enough to put on a ballot. The state would commit to the public side of a franchise pursuit — site control, infrastructure, a stadium or arena authority, and the governor’s convening power with a league office. Monroe County voters would choose the sport: the NBA, Major League Baseball, or Major League Soccer. The ownership group would still have to be real. The league would still have to say yes. The referendum would decide which door the state knocks on.
That is a political idea. It is also a market question, and the three doors are not the same height.
The market, as it actually is
The Rochester metropolitan area has about 1.06 million people, 54th in the country, and it is not growing. The Census Bureau’s 2025 estimate put the MSA at 1,056,149, down from 1.09 million in 2020. The television market is smaller than the population suggests. Nielsen ranks Rochester 79th, with roughly 436,000 TV households. Buffalo, an hour and a quarter west, is a larger DMA. Toronto, across the lake, is a top-ten North American media market with a team in every league that matters.
The local economy is real and narrower than a suite chart wants. Regional GDP was about $75 billion in 2022. The University of Rochester and its medical center are the dominant employer, on the order of 36,000 jobs. Rochester Regional Health is next. Wegmans is headquartered on Brooks Avenue and is a national brand, but it is private and family-held. Paychex is the conspicuous public company. Constellation Brands sits in Victor, inside the metro. The old Kodak and Xerox payrolls are not coming back. Universities and hospital systems buy some hospitality. They do not buy thirty NBA suites at Manhattan prices.
The sports culture is older than the corporate base. The Rochester Red Wings have played professional baseball in the city without interruption since the nineteenth century, and Frontier Field has been a full International League house for a generation. The Americans are a serious AHL club. In August 2025 the Seneca Nation bought the Knighthawks from Pegula Sports and Entertainment and kept the National Lacrosse League franchise in the city. Blue Cross Arena, the old War Memorial, holds 10,662 for hockey and tops out around 12,400 for an end-stage event. It is a good minor league building. It is not a major league building, and everyone in the league offices already knows that.
The NBA: the historical claim, and the worst math
Rochester’s basketball case is the only one that starts with a championship. The Rochester Royals won the NBA title in 1951. They played at the Edgerton Park Sports Arena, left for Cincinnati in 1957, and after Kansas City and Omaha and Kansas City again became the Sacramento Kings. A return would be a restoration story, and restoration stories are how leagues sell expansion to their own fans.
It is also the bid the numbers reject first.
The NBA’s smallest current markets are not small in Rochester’s sense. Memphis, New Orleans, and Oklahoma City all sit near DMA 50, with metro populations in the 1.3 to 1.5 million range and television households well above Rochester’s 436,000. The league’s next expansion, which owners voted in March 2026 to explore, is Seattle and Las Vegas, with franchise fees discussed at $7 billion to $10 billion before the cost of a building. A modern NBA arena runs $800 million to well over $1 billion, and the building Rochester has seats about 12,000. No ownership group writing a check in that range is going to put the team in a DMA that ranks 79th, an hour from an existing NHL market and a short flight from Toronto, New York, and Boston.
A governor can clear a site and can lean on a legislature for an arena authority. He cannot manufacture local media revenue, and local media is what still separates the Memphis Grizzlies from a romantic relaunch of the Royals. The basketball bid is the one Rochester would love and the one the league will not take.
MLB: the deepest habit, and a market smaller than every club already in
Baseball is the sport Rochester already supports at the highest level it has been offered. The Red Wings are not a novelty franchise. They are the reason a major league bid here would not have to teach the city the sport. Eighty-one home dates is a product this market already understands, in a way it does not understand twenty MLS dates or forty-one NBA dates.
The fit problem is scale. Every existing MLB market is larger. Milwaukee, Cincinnati, Kansas City, Cleveland, and Pittsburgh — the usual list of small-market clubs — all have bigger metros and, more decisively, bigger television markets. Rochester at DMA 79 would be the smallest media market in the league by a wide margin. Expansion fees are now discussed around $2 billion and up, and a retractable-roof ballpark in this climate, which a club would need if it wanted April and October to be commercial products rather than endurance tests, is a separate billion-dollar project. Frontier Field cannot be stretched into that building.
Territory is cleaner here than it would be in Brooklyn. The New York Mets’ claim on the city is a live issue for any New York baseball bid. Nobody holds an MLB territorial right over Rochester. Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Toronto, and the two New York clubs are all far enough away that a Rochester club would not be asking to share a city. It would be asking the league to believe a flat, 1.06-million-person metro can carry a big-league gate for eighty-one dates. The league has not believed that about any American city this size in the modern expansion era. Montreal is the cautionary case, and Montreal was bigger.
What baseball has, and the other two do not, is a ready-made regional draw and a century of attendance data. If a governor were going to spend political capital on one long-shot bid, baseball is the one where the fan base does not have to be invented. It is also the one where the public subsidy, per dollar of private franchise value, would be the most exposed.
MLS: the only door that is not fantasy
Soccer is the bid that survives contact with a spreadsheet.
Major League Soccer has spent fifteen years selling itself into markets the older leagues had already passed on, and it has priced expansion accordingly. San Diego’s fee was $500 million. Club values in the 2026 Sportico table average $767 million, with Inter Miami an outlier at $1.45 billion because of Lionel Messi, not because of Miami’s DMA. A soccer-specific stadium of 18,000 to 22,000 seats is a $250 million to $400 million project, not a $1.2 billion enclosed baseball palace and not a $1 billion NBA arena. The schedule is summer and early fall, which is the part of the Rochester year when you can actually hold an outdoor event without a roof.
Rochester would still be small for MLS. Cincinnati, Columbus, Austin, Nashville, and Salt Lake City — the recent expansion class — are all larger metros, and their television markets sit in the 30s, not the 70s. A Rochester club would be the smallest media market in the league. The difference is that MLS has already decided small markets are a strategy rather than a problem, provided the building is controlled, the ownership group is solvent, and the city will treat twenty home dates as an event rather than a routine.
The ownership path is also less theoretical than it is for the other two. The Seneca Nation just bought a Rochester franchise and said, in public, that the city is home. That was lacrosse, not soccer, and a Nation that already operates casinos and a holding company is not automatically an MLS bidder. It is, however, a regional principal that has already written a check to keep a professional team in Blue Cross Arena. Wegmans is the other obvious civic call, the way the Haslams were in Columbus and the Gilberts were not required to be in every MLS city. A governor who can put the Seneca Nation, a Rochester corporate patriarch, and a site on the river or at the edge of downtown in the same room has the beginning of a bid. He does not have that for a $8 billion basketball franchise.
What the state can actually deliver
Leagues do not award teams to governors. They award them to owners who can pay the fee, control a building, and survive a background check. The state’s piece is the building, the land, the infrastructure, and the signal that the public sector will not spend a decade litigating the site.
That is why the referendum is the interesting part of the idea, and also the risky part. Asking Monroe County to choose among the NBA, MLB, and MLS will produce a sentimental vote for the Royals or the Red Wings. The market will not honor that vote. A governor who campaigns on “you pick” and then discovers the NBA will not return a call has handed his opponent a press release. A governor who tells Rochester the truth — that soccer is the franchise the market can carry, that baseball is the franchise the culture deserves and cannot afford, and that basketball is a memory — is asking a city to be more cold-blooded than cities usually are about their own sports.
Rochester can support a major league club in one of these three sports, and only one of them has an expansion price, a building cost, and a calendar that fit inside a metro of a million people with a flat population and a 79th-ranked television market.
Be the first to comment