Hochul may launch a ‘Regionalism Prize’ to incentivize mergers of local governments

(DECEMBER 19, 2021) — Governor Kathy Hochul is considering a new set of intergovernmental transfer payments that are designed to encourage the merger and consolidation of local municipal governments — and she plans to announce the program in her State of the State speech next month.

The incentives are being called ‘The Regionalism Prize‘, in the hope that local municipalities will streamline, consolidate, or dissolve their operations in exchange for infrastructure money that would be used to revitalize local village centers and historic downtown areas.

Use of the money would be limited to streetscape improvements including innovative lighting schemes, public space enhancements, pedestrian infrastructure, facade restorations, street furniture, educational signage, public art, and community-led historic preservation projects.

“We want to invest in communities that are willing to work together and to collaborate,” a Hochul attache explains.  “If local leaders are willing to do the hard work of forging a regionalism consensus, Governor Hochul wants to empower those grassroots movements inspired towards regional collaboration.”

Here are some of the details:

Village-Town Merger Prize.  Any village board that votes to dissolve its own government in order to merge with an adjacent municipality would be awarded $25 million in revitalization funding.  While that funding would be administered by the consolidated successor municipality, it would be designated for use in the village that is voting to dissolve itself.

Town-Town Merger Prize.  Any town board that votes to dissolve its own government in order to merge with an adjacent town would be awarded $50 million in revitalization funding.  While that funding would be administered by the consolidated successor municipality, it would be designated for use in the principal historic commercial district of the town that is voting to dissolve itself.

Multi-Town Merger Prize.  For any three towns that vote to consolidate their governments, the State would award $100 million in downtown revitalization funding, with an extra $50 million awarded for each additional town that is included in the merger.  Therefore, a merger of six towns would earn that community $250 million in revitalization funds.  Those funds could be used for revitalization initiatives in multiple historic commercial districts.

County-City Merger Prize.  For any City that serves as the seat of its County government and whose City Council votes to dissolve and fully consolidate its operations with the County’s operations, that City would be awarded $200 million in downtown revitalization funds.  While that funding would be administered by the county legislature, it would be designated for use in the principal historic commercial district of the City that is voting to dissolve itself.

County-County Merger Prize. Any two adjacent county legislatures that each vote to consolidate their operations under a reconstituted legislative body would be awarded $350 million in revitalization funding.  That shared fund would grow by an additional $250 million for every additional County that participates in the merger.  Therefore, a merger of eight counties would be awarded $1.9 billion in revitalization funds.

The incentive structure is intended to motivate large, multi-government mergers in communities that organize themselves aggressively enough to secure the majority support of the participating local governments’ legislative bodies.

 

Hochul believes that regions across Upstate, Central, and Western New York would be interested in participating in the regionalism program. The Rochester Finger Lakes region is thought to be particularly keen on such a program, which has been privately endorsed by former Lt. Governor Bob Duffy.

 

If the City of Canandaigua votes to merge with the Town of Canandaigua, the City would see $50 million of downtown revitalization investments in its historic downtown center.  If that merger were also to include the adjacent towns of Hopewell and Gorham, that community’s downtown revitalization fund would grow to $150 million. 

 

If the City of Canandaigua instead, as the seat of Ontario County, was to dissolve its operations into the County’s, the City would see $200 million in downtown revitalization funds.  A County-City merger would not impact the operations of towns other than the City that is being dissolved.  But if all two Cities, eight villages, and 16 towns in the county merged, they would see $1.2 billion in downtown revitalization funding. 

6 Comments

  1. Why does she want them to merge/dissolve? How does the consolidation of power benefit the citizens? Please note, I did NOT ask how the INCENTIVE money benefits them, so please do not say that’s how.

  2. Don’t believe a word this woman says. It’s all to make it easier for NYC to control upstate and the state is already $60bil in debt with more businesses and people leaving in droves.

    http://www.divideNY.org is where we split from NYC into Autonomous Regions and is already on the move. Links for Facebook and Telegram are there too. THAT is the movement that needs to happen so we can finally make our own decisions.

    • Kathy Houchul does not have the best interest if this state on her mind it is to control every district and county. She will destroy this state if you let her.. don’t listen to this bullshit she is handing out.

  3. Well, City County mergers amounts to a kind of gerrymandering. More rural and suburban (read more Republican) unincorporated county districts would be swamped with more urban (read Democrat) cities.

    Also, this scheme facilitates central control. The less constituent municipalities there are, the easier it is to focus political power on them. More importantly, we have anough big government with no end in sight on the Federal governmetn taking power over our daily lives. (When ithe last time you saw your Congress people on the stree, and not at an event?)

    On the other hand, there are a lot of small governments out there. Each has its own overhead, and requires its own talent pool. Like sports franchises, you need enough for all the markets, but few enough that talent isn’ tdiluted. Government is pretty complex business these days, even for small ones.

  4. Here’s a better idea HOchul… every county secedes from the STATE of New York. Take my taxpayer funds and shove it my county will not bend.

Leave a Reply