County Legislature candidate was involved in shooting at an East Side bar, but circumstances remain unclear

Democrat Party Chairman Jeremy Zellner and Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz are running Howard Johnson for the County Legislature in District 1, largely to undermine Mayor Byron Brown's political organization.

Howard Johnson is a candidate for County Legislature in District 1 — the seat that former City Comptroller Barbara Miller-Williams vacated upon her appointment by Mayor Byron Brown to become City Comptroller.

Sources say that several years ago Johnson was shot at Pandora’s Sports Bar, a tavern on Fillmore Avenue with a reputation for a good fish fry by day, and a young hard-partying crowd by night.  The venue has been the site of multiple shootings over many years, and homicides frequent the sidewalk in front of the establishment.

Pandora’s Sports Bar is located on Fillmore Avenue at Victoria Avenue.

The circumstances surrounding Johnson being shot have remained unclear, and the candidate has not commented on how often he frequents the establishment.

Johnson’s critics have been calling on him to discuss the incident publicly and to take questions at a press conference on the subject.

Johnson was endorsed by Erie County Executive Mark Poloncarz.  Many local operatives interpret the move as part of a broader effort by Poloncarz and Erie County Democratic Chairman Jeremy Zellner to undermine Mayor Brown’s political organization.

Johnson is the ‘political enforcer’ of Arthur Eve, Jr., the Deputy Commissioner of the Erie County Board of Elections, a Zellner operative.  Zellner orchestrated Johnson’s appointment to the vacancy a few weeks ago.

Miller-Williams is a close Brown ally and was seen as an independent voice on the County Legislature.  The departure of former City Comptroller Mark Schroeder for a position with the Department of Motor Vehicles was seen as a blow to the Zellner-Poloncarz machine.

In recent months the two men have been doing all they can to ensure that headquarters Democrats — rather than opposition Democrats — retake control of the District 1 seat.

Screen Shot 2019-05-28 at 2.34.00 PM



  1. This is written in a tone that implies that the candidate did something wrong. If this is true, why is this website going after a victim of a crime? Seems unfair to me.

  2. Zellner and Poloncarz are Republicans are they not? So they’re endorsing Howard Johnson for a county Legislator seat, not a councilmatic seat. Johnson has every right to run, but is he running as a democratic or Republican? I’m more interested in who he runs against ! And Art Eve is endorsing a candidate who has the backing of the Republican party? Kind of ironic isn’t it?

Leave a Reply