Attorney General’s investigation of Steve Pigeon is politically motivated

New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman has been roundly criticized for failing to pursue public corruption cases against elected officials who have been accused of enriching themselves with public dollars.

So it is curious, they say, that he would allocate law enforcement resources into investigating a much more minor charge against the lobbyist G. Steven Pigeon, a former Chairman of the Erie County Democratic Party and an active figure in New York politics.

Pigeon, an intrepid political insider who engages in politics like sport, contributed $100,000 in personal savings to a PAC, managed by the political operative Kristy Mazurek. By all accounts, both are well versed in the legalities surrounding campaign spending and political action committees and insist that they adhered to those laws strictly.

Pigeon’s earnings are in “the mid-six figures”, the Buffalo News reports. He is of counsel at the Rochester based law firm of Underberg & Kessler. His client list includes powerful politicians, multinational firms, and some of the state’s corporate mainstays.

His contribution to the PAC was used for mailers and field staff in local county legislative races. It was his own money used for political speech, as is allowable under campaign finance laws and a constitutionally protected right.

The investigation was prompted by the Attorney General after being prompted by County Legislator Betty Jean Grant, who challenged State Senator Tim Kennedy in the Democratic primary last year and remains bitterly angry that the party didn’t coalesce around her following her receipt of the party’s endorsement. Pigeon supported Kennedy.

Political observers say the investigation is a politically charged abuse of power that will backfire on the sitting Attorney General, whose central participation in the Moreland Commission debacle has raised serious ethics questions inside his office.

Pigeon is close to Governor Andrew Cuomo, who is at odds with Scheiderman. In political circles, the AG is rumored to have cut a deal with US Attorney Preet Bharara on the Moreland Commission corruption scandal. Schneiderman’s deputizing of Commission members implicates him all sorts of legal improprieties. It’s rumored that he cut a deal to insulate himself from the scandal, but that has not been confirmed by either office.


Cuomo and Schneiderman have since been feuding intensely behind the scenes. Local operatives surmise that the AG is going after Pigeon as part of the tit-for-tat back and forth with the Governor’s political machine.

Schneiderman is known to be ambitious with his eyes set on the Governor’s mansion. Operatives close to Cuomo say that Schneiderman saw an opening to scandalize the Governor and, potentially, push him out of office.

ClintonPigeonObservers note that aggressiveness in politics is often met with an equal and opposite response. They think that the AG’s maneuvering will backfire, and that he could even be brought up on abuse of power charges. That is yet to be seen and very far from certain.

We will be following how it all plays out.



1 Comment

  1. I don’t think politicians want Pigeon’s political advice. They want the money he can get for their campaign. He’s great a fundraising. You have to give him credit for that.

    I also think he’s been breaking the law for many, many years, and prosecutors have given him a pass not because of his connections, rather they don’t care much about these minor election law offenses when violent crime is so much more important – except of course if your name is Joseph Mascia.

    But the political strategy that some of the historical local figures are known for, like Svengalis bestowing wise and calculating political moves and winning, is exactly what Pigeon wants people to believe of him. When he did have the chance to show his stuff, that is when he was the Democratic chairman, his strategy came up very short his entire run.

    So what’s the difference between those sad days for Pigeon and the Democratic Party locally, and now? Not much, I guess, Pigeon’s still doing great raising money but his political advice is pretty much like it was when his people continued to come up short – especially candidates who were running for judicial offices, where Pigeon had a terrible run of it.

    Looking back to the campaign that ignited the latest in Pigeon’s many investigations, I remember one of Rick Zydel’s campaign managers being interviewed about Pigeon’s role in the Zydel campaign. The manager, who was defending Zydel and saying Pigeon was not involved in the campaign strategy, said they really didn’t want Pigeon’s advice anyway. He said that at their meetings, Pigeon comes in, gives them stupid political ideas, and a check. They ignore his advice, according to the Zydel aide, but grab the money.

    I just can’t see Steve Pigeon ever getting the “Svengali” reputation that he so desperately has yearned for all of these years. You either have it or you don’t. And Pigeon doesn’t. However, he is a good fundraiser. But good fundraisers come “one dime for one dozen.”

Leave a Reply