Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

Niagara Falls wants its $210 million arena to be the city’s new front door. Its own study says the site has no room to grow

As the Niagara Falls City Council again weighs a development corporation to build Mayor Robert Restaino’s 6,000-seat arena, the city’s own feasibility study says the 10-acre site off John B. Daly Boulevard has “no future growth potential” and leaves its soil condition “TBD.”

A quiet street lined with vacant lots and a boarded-up house, with the blue-glass Seneca Niagara hotel tower in the distance. Photo: Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

By Simon Achterberg

NIAGARA FALLS, N.Y. — The architects who drew Niagara Falls’ proposed downtown arena describe the site off John B. Daly Boulevard as a future “new iconic arrival point or gateway into the City.” The city’s own feasibility study describes the same land more bluntly: it is just big enough, and no bigger.

The City Council is scheduled to vote again Wednesday on whether to form a local development corporation to build and run the project, a 6,000-seat arena and events complex that Mayor Robert Restaino has pushed since 2021 under the placeholder name Centennial Park. The council has put off the question at least twice. The revised plan would give the corporation a seven-member board, according to the Niagara Gazette.

The fight at City Hall has been about money and control. Less has been said about what would be built and how it would fit on the land.

What the plans show

The concept comes from Buffalo-based CJS Architects, which says it worked with the city to envision “a multifaceted, year-round event campus” meant to keep visitors in town through the winter, when tourism falls off. The firm’s project page lists a multi-purpose indoor arena, an outdoor amphitheater, “a multilevel parking structure with a climbing wall” and an outdoor adventure course.

The feasibility report the city commissioned from Sports Facilities Advisory, dated April 2025 and posted on the city’s website, recommends a narrower program. It calls for a two-level arena of about 180,000 square feet with 6,000 fixed seats and room for 7,000, a separate community rink with 500 seats, an outdoor plaza and 800 surface parking spaces. Neither the amphitheater nor a parking garage appears in its recommended program.

Parking is the biggest single use of the land in that plan. The study puts the arena at 2.41 acres and the community rink at 1.05 acres, and assigns 8.58 acres to “site development.” The 800 parking spaces would take up about 62 percent of that, or roughly 5.3 acres. It says off-site parking “may be required for larger events,” and lists lots within a 15-minute walk, including the Seneca Niagara casino’s.

A wide four-lane street at a signalized intersection, with traffic lights, green route signs and a tall blue-glass hotel tower at right
Rainbow Boulevard (Route 384) approaching John B. Daly Boulevard in downtown Niagara Falls in July 2023, with the Seneca Niagara hotel tower at right. The proposed arena site lies east of the casino along John B. Daly Boulevard. Photo: Mr. Matté via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

A site with ‘no future growth potential’

The report scored only two locations. The site east of the casino, then called the Centennial Park site, scored 58 of a possible 80 points. A former Rainbow Mall site on Rainbow Boulevard scored 48. The study said that site “would not easily accommodate” the complex and would lack on-site parking.

“With approximately 10 acres available for development, there is no future growth potential for the site,” the scorecard says. Elsewhere, the same report calls the parcel about 12 acres and says the full complex needs about 12.

The scorecard marks the condition of the site, including its soil and substructure, as “TBD.” It warns that “existing infrastructure located on site could impact timeframe for completion.” And it says traffic “could be more notably affected during tournament and event weekends.” It cites a separate Centennial Park traffic study that is not posted with the report.

At a Nov. 4 council meeting, speakers raised concerns about possible radioactive contamination on Royal Avenue “and near the proposed sports complex,” the Niagara Express reported. The public record does not show whether the arena site has been tested.

The land is the city’s now. Paying for the rest is the fight

The city now controls the land, at 907 Falls Street. After a court order, it paid Niagara Falls Redevelopment $4.029 million from its unassigned fund balance under a settlement that also cleared the way for the company’s data center campus next door, WKBW reported. Councilmember Bridgette Myles had opposed paying from that account. “Not the general fund, that’s taxpayers’ money,” she told the station.

The building is the bigger bill. The feasibility study estimated total costs from about $178.7 million to $217.7 million, not counting land. The Gazette now describes the project as costing $210 million. When Restaino first unveiled it in 2021, it was estimated at $150 million, the Gazette has reported.

The local development corporation is how the mayor proposes to pay for it. Under the plan described by the city’s attorneys, the corporation would issue bonds backed by arena revenue, including tickets, concessions, naming rights and leases. “The resolution itself expressly provides that nothing in it authorizes the incurrence of any indebtedness by the city, the pledge of the city’s credit, or any expenditure of city funds,” the city’s legal counsel told the Gazette in an email this summer.

The study’s operating forecast, though, is small next to a project of that size. It projects the arena’s earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization at about $104,000 in its first year, rising to about $511,000 by year five. The report does not say how construction would be financed.

Who decides

Restaino has called the corporation model “a proven structure for delivering a major public facility, and it is the right approach for Niagara Falls,” according to CNHI.

Council Chairman Brian Archie led the Nov. 4 move to table the vote, seeking a larger board and plainer language on liability. “I believe we should give (the city) the ability to do (economic development) — but no city dollars should go to it,” he said, according to CNHI. Councilmember James Perry, who sponsored the resolution, was the only member opposed to tabling it. “We keep throwing roadblocks into this,” Perry said.

Councilmember Vincent Cauley has called the arena the mayor’s “vanity project.” “This is not the route we should be taking,” he told the Gazette earlier this month. “The city should not be in this development and we should not be establishing a body that subverts the council like the urban renewal agency or the NFC Development Corp. already does.”

The American Falls at dusk with mist rising, and downtown Niagara Falls hotel towers, including the lit Seneca Niagara tower, on the skyline behind
The American Falls at dusk in June 2012, with downtown Niagara Falls behind it and the lit Seneca Niagara hotel tower. The city wants a year-round draw for the winter months. Photo: saychinqua1 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

What the design still has to answer

Restaino has said he hopes to break ground in 2028, according to WKBW. Downtown price tags have a way of moving: the Buffalo Chronicle reported last week that the Hotel Niagara’s restoration has carried six price tags.

Before then, the public has not seen a site plan showing where 800 cars, a community rink and a 7,000-person arena would fit on about 10 acres, or how event traffic would reach John B. Daly Boulevard. Nor is it clear which campus is planned: the architects’ amphitheater and climbing-wall garage, or the consultant’s arena, rink and surface lots. The soil questions the study left as “TBD” remain open in the public record.

The Buffalo Chronicle is seeking comment from Restaino’s office and the City Council on the site plan, the traffic study and environmental testing, and will update this story with any response.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements