Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

·

Buffalo’s school board is set to vote Wednesday on a closure plan rewritten two days earlier. A board member says it saves $7 million less

The revised plan would close six schools, convert a seventh and return five buildings to the city, moving Da Vinci and Research Lab into Drew and Middle Early College into Riverside. Board member Larry Scott says projected savings fell from $24 million to $17 million.

East High School in Buffalo, a long four-story tan brick school building with tall windows, under a cloudy sky. Photo: Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

By Nora Kowalczyk

BUFFALO — The Buffalo Board of Education is scheduled to vote Wednesday night on a plan to close six schools, convert a seventh and hand five buildings back to the city, a plan the district rewrote again two days before the meeting. The newest version, posted Monday under the board’s agenda, moves three high schools to different buildings than the last draft did. By one board member’s account, it is also projected to save $7 million less than the plan the interim superintendent first proposed.

The plan needs five votes on the nine-member board, The Buffalo News reported. It sits at the center of a four-year fiscal stability plan the district says it needs to avoid a cash crisis: the district’s chief financial officer told the board this month that without a decision on “right-sizing,” the district faces a $90 million to $100 million gap for 2027-28 and could run out of cash in December 2027, as the Chronicle reported. The meeting begins at 5:30 p.m. at West Hertel Academy, 489 Hertel Ave.

What the latest plan does

Interim Superintendent Ebony Prophet-Bullock submitted the revised resolution Monday, Nov. 16. Under it, Leonardo da Vinci High School and Research Laboratory High School would move into the building of Dr. Charles R. Drew Science Magnet School 59, which is attached to the Buffalo Museum of Science in Martin Luther King Jr. Park. Drew, a school for third through eighth graders, has been slated to close under every version of the plan, according to The News.

Middle Early College High School, which has long shared a building with Lewis J. Bennett School of Innovative Technology on Main Street, would get a building of its own: Riverside Academy’s home at 51 Ontario St. Riverside Academy would phase out over three years rather than relocate its students before next school year, and current Riverside freshmen would be allowed to apply to Middle Early, The News reported.

The Academy School at 131, the district’s alternative program, would close and reboot as Buffalo Rising Academy inside the East Community High School building on Northampton Street. East would close, and its building would also house the Career Collegiate Institute, WGRZ reported, citing the resolution and a district spokesperson.

Early Childhood Center School 17, a pre-kindergarten through fourth grade school near Canisius University, would close and become the district’s central registration and welcome center. Bilingual Center School 33 in the Old First Ward would close and become an information technology center and administrative building. Early Childhood Center School 90 would become a pre-kindergarten special education center, which district officials have said does not count as a closure.

Five buildings would be returned to the City of Buffalo, including the current Academy School at 131 building and several administrative buildings, according to the district’s list as reported by Spectrum News.

The Buffalo Museum of Science, a stone building with a green dome, seen across a plaza in winter
The Buffalo Museum of Science in Martin Luther King Jr. Park. Dr. Charles R. Drew Science Magnet School 59, attached to the museum, would close, and its building would house Da Vinci and Research Laboratory high schools under the revised plan. (Photo: Pubdog via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

How the plan got here

Prophet-Bullock first released the proposal Oct. 2. As first presented, it would have closed eight schools starting in the 2027-28 school year and eliminated more than 100 jobs, and she said it would save the district $24 million a year, Spectrum News reported.

“The success of this proposal will not be measured by only one number of buildings changed, it will be measured by whether students enter stronger, sustainable educational settings and whether the district is better positioned to invest in teaching, learning and support over the long term,” Prophet-Bullock said at the time.

Families pushed back early. At the first public hearing, PS 33 parent Timothy Monreal worried about where the Bilingual Center’s children would land. “Eighty percent of our students are from east or south Buffalo — what does that mean, that they would have to go all the way across town?” he told Spectrum News.

By the Oct. 21 board meeting at McKinley High School, the plan had already been revised, and the board was set to vote. It didn’t. After emotional testimony from Riverside students, Prophet-Bullock interrupted public comment. “We heard you. We’re pulling it. We will not be voting on it today,” she said, Buffalo Toronto Public Media reported. She acknowledged the district had fallen short in explaining its changes. “We’re not doing enough, and we will do better,” she said.

Buffalo Teachers Federation President Rich Nigro had urged the board to slow down. “This is not ripping off a Band-Aid; it’s pulling out stitches, stitches that are holding communities together,” he told the board.

Some students welcomed parts of that earlier revision. Da Vinci student Kelani Hickey thanked district leaders for keeping Da Vinci and Research Lab as separate schools in a shared building. “We are not against change. We simply want change that benefits our education without taking away the identity of our school,” she said. Riverside senior Letitia Sadile asked the board, “Why can’t we find a solution where everyone has a place where nobody has to lose their family to make room for someone else?”

East Community High School Principal Tracy Cotter asked the board to weigh which neighborhoods would bear the cost. “If we can calculate how many dollars will be saved, then surely we can calculate who will be asked to pay the human price,” she said. At a community forum five days later, Prophet-Bullock told 7 News WKBW, “I think it’s fair to say there will be some modifications,” as the Chronicle reported at the time.

Three high schools, four addresses

The plan’s high school moves have shifted more than any other part. Da Vinci and Research Lab were first slated to merge into one school in Riverside Academy’s building. After the Da Vinci community pushed back, the two were kept as separate schools sharing a building. A later district update moved them into the building East Community High School would vacate, for transportation reasons. Now they would go to the Drew building.

Middle Early College was not in the Oct. 2 proposal at all. After several board members urged district leaders to find the specialty school its own home, it entered the plan before the Oct. 21 meeting, slated for East’s building, The News reported. In the newest version, it gets Riverside’s.

That swap is what has Riverside’s staff most upset. “Middle Early College is now evicting Riverside students and they only have 16 more students than we do,” longtime Riverside teacher Marc Bruno told WBEN. “Most of our students (at Riverside) live in the neighborhood. Many of them are at-risk students. They don’t speak fluent English or are special ed.”

Bruno said Riverside parents, students and staff plan to turn out Wednesday and are weighing legal action against the district. He said the late changes were a pattern. “This whole thing has been mishandled,” he said. He went further, accusing the district of targeting the school: “We firmly believe that we are being targeted because we’re the only school that speaks up against district corruption, incompetence and the mishandling of financial resources.” The district has not publicly responded to that accusation.

The front of Riverside High School in Buffalo, a three-story stone building with a wide stairway, framed by a large tree
Riverside Academy’s building at 51 Ontario St. in 2012. Under the revised plan, Middle Early College High School would move in, and Riverside Academy would phase out over three years. (Photo: D-Day via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)

A board member’s objections

Board member Larry Scott has raised the sharpest questions from inside the board. He told WGRZ on Tuesday that the new plan saves less than the first one did. “I don’t believe that this is the best that we can do. The initial plan would have saved us $24 million — projected $24 million — and this most current plan is projected to save us $17 million,” he said.

He also questioned why Middle Early College would get its own building while two larger schools share one. “When we are talking about the need to merge, right-size, and now we’re giving Early Middle College its own building, opening up space at the Bennett campus and forcing da Vinci and Research Lab to co-locate when da Vinci has a higher student enrollment than Middle Early, that to me, it’s just not adding up,” Scott said.

Scott said he won’t support closing School 17. “School 17 is a pre-K through fourth-grade school that serves almost 50 percent of students with disabilities, some of them quite severe, so that is a building that I do not support closing,” he said.

And he said the late changes cost the district trust. “This is a traumatic experience for so many that are potentially going to be displaced, that are hearing about their school being closed or moved. And then we experience the abrupt changes without good explanation. It causes more distrust,” he said.

What the district says

Prophet-Bullock has framed the newest draft as the board’s plan, not hers. “As Interim Superintendent, on October 2 I released a school closures proposal for consideration by the community and for an eventual vote by the Board of Education,” she wrote in a statement Monday, The News reported.

“After listening to the many voices of our community, the board chose to make changes. It is my responsibility to carry out the direction of the Board of Education, I submitted an updated resolution Monday, November 16 that upholds the Board’s changes to the school closures proposal for consideration by the Board at its monthly meeting on Wednesday, November 18,” she wrote. “Until the Board takes additional action on Wednesday, neither my administration nor I will make any further comments.”

That puts the decision, and the accountability for it, squarely with the nine members of the board. Their vote follows a warning from the district’s own finance office. At a board workshop this month, Chief Financial Officer James Barnes described the cost of doing nothing. “Assuming there’s no decision on the right-sizing plan for the ‘27-‘28 year, an initial maintenance of effort projection shows a $90 million to $100 million deficit,” he said, WGRZ reported. That figure, he said, includes raises and contract costs “for all 7,700 employees, and no reductions to any facilities, maintenance, utilities, classrooms, anything.”

What the numbers don’t yet show

The public record so far leaves several questions open. The district has published the list of buildings but not, in any document the Chronicle could find, a building-by-building accounting of what each closure saves. That accounting would show where the $7 million gap Scott described comes from. The district also hasn’t publicly explained what the three-year Riverside phase-out costs compared with an immediate move, or how it squares with the 2027-28 savings target.

Families at affected schools have asked for things the plan doesn’t yet spell out: bus routes and ride times for children who would be sent across the city, where special education services at School 17 would go, and how many of the more than 100 jobs in the first plan remain on the line. Cotter’s question at McKinley, about which neighborhoods pay the human price, also has no published answer. The district has not released an analysis of the closures by neighborhood or by the students each school serves.

Some of those questions could be answered before the first building changes hands. The board could require the administration to publish projected savings for each building, a transportation plan for each displaced school and a timeline for the five buildings going back to the city before any move takes effect. Each would give families a way to check the plan’s promises against its results.

Even if the resolution passes Wednesday, the closures would not take effect until the 2027-28 school year, and the district’s fiscal stability plan runs four years. If it fails, the CFO’s warning stands: without a decision, the district’s finance office projects a deficit of up to $100 million and a cash shortfall by the end of 2027.

The Chronicle is seeking comment from Buffalo Public Schools on the savings estimates and the Riverside phase-out, and will update this report with any response. The agenda and the revised resolution are posted on the board’s BoardDocs site, The News reported, and a district notice sets the meeting for 5:30 p.m. at West Hertel Academy, WNYmedia reported.

Sources: The Buffalo News, Nov. 16 (revised resolution details, Prophet-Bullock statement); WGRZ, Nov. 16 and Nov. 17 (Larry Scott interview); WIVB, Nov. 16; WBEN, Nov. 17 (Marc Bruno); Spectrum News, Oct. 8 and Nov. 17; Buffalo Toronto Public Media, Oct. 22; WNYmedia, Nov. 17; Buffalo Chronicle reporting on Nov. 3 and Nov. 13. Featured photo: East High School, Buffalo, by Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements