By Nora Kowalczyk
BUFFALO — Buffalo’s proactive rental inspection program has now checked 18,235 rental units since 2020 and found lead hazards in 5,214 of them, according to the latest status report from the city’s permits and inspections commissioner, filed with the Common Council on Nov. 10. Over the same period the city has issued 4,159 Certificates of Rental Compliance, the document landlords need to rent a property or evict for nonpayment, according to Investigative Post.
The report also records what has not happened: inspectors have sought zero warrants to get into homes, and the table reports no rental registration unit certificates issued by the department. The council’s Community Development Committee takes up the report Tuesday at 2 p.m., according to its agenda. The Chronicle read the full report, which runs seven pages in the council’s 618-page meeting packet, and set it against earlier reporting and court records to see what it shows and what it leaves out.
What the commissioner’s report counts
The report, signed by Commissioner Louis Petrucci of the Department of Permit and Inspection Services (DPIS), is filed under Chapter 264-13(B) of the city code. It is the clearest published count of how the program Buffalo created in 2020 is performing. Its first exhibit lists inspections by year:
- 2020: 445 units inspected
- 2021: 1,637
- 2022: 2,252
- 2023: 293
- 2024: 2,651
- 2025: 6,213
- January through Sept. 30, 2026: 4,744
The sharp dip in 2023 is a counting change, not a collapse. The report explains that during the pandemic many residents were reluctant to let inspectors inside, so the first three years include exterior-only inspections. “Following the decline of COVID-19 concerns, starting in 2023, only homes with interior-exterior inspections have been recorded,” it says.
Since 2023 the report counts 7,115 unique rental properties inspected, 1,653 of them this year. It also lists 8,896 units that needed more than one inspection, a figure that suggests the 18,235 total includes repeat visits to some of the same homes.
Petrucci’s narrative is upbeat. “Based upon the data received to date, we are on track to surpass both the number of rental registrations, revenues generated by rental registration, and proactive property inspections conducted last year,” he wrote. The 2026 pace supports that: 4,744 inspections in nine months works out to about 6,300 a year, by the Chronicle’s calculation, slightly above 2025’s 6,213.

The gap between inspections and certificates
The program’s stated target is far larger. DPIS has said it aims to inspect and license 30,000 units every three years, according to Investigative Post. At about 6,300 inspections a year, the Chronicle calculates, the city would reach roughly 19,000 in three years, about 63% of that goal, if every counted inspection were a separate unit, which the report suggests is not the case.
The bigger question is what happens after the inspector leaves. Of the 18,235 inspections, the report counts 4,159 certificates issued: 36 in 2021, 120 in 2022, 213 in 2023, 782 in 2024, 1,725 in 2025 and 1,283 through Sept. 30. The report does not say whether a certificate covers a property or a unit, how many inspected homes passed on the first visit, or how many are still waiting on repairs. Those are the numbers that would show whether inspections are turning into safer housing.
Petrucci acknowledges the lag. “One of the main challenges is still the amount of time between inspection and the issuance of a Certificate of Rental Compliance (CRC),” the report says, attributing it to “lack of resources, paucity of contractors willing to perform the repairs, scheduling conflicts, etc., and in some cases, a purposeful failure to comply.”
The department says it is fixing some of that. It has funding for 60 tablets, delivered in two batches of 30, and plans to launch a mobile inspection application, Inform Mobile, on Dec. 1. It is also exploring a software module that would let the program send notices by text and email and “perform billing functions.” Staff have met with Syracuse about its program and, when the report was written, were scheduled to meet with Rochester.
Where the lead and the violations are
The report says lead hazards were found in 1,118 of the 6,213 units inspected in 2025 (18%) and 1,033 of 4,744 so far this year (22%), by the Chronicle’s math. The report’s footnote says the entry reflects properties with protective-treatment or interior-surface violations, which include chipping and peeling paint. The early years were worse: hazards in 330 of 445 units in 2020 and 1,198 of 2,252 in 2022.
Exhibit Two counts 8,200 violations from Jan. 1 to Sept. 30, 2026, across all nine council districts. The Masten District, on the East Side, accounts for 2,974 of them, 36%. The University District had 1,063, Ellicott 1,032, Fillmore 685, Delaware 675, Niagara 663, Lovejoy 644, North 302 and South 162.
Those totals reflect where inspectors have been as much as where housing is worst. The city has been scheduling inspections “methodically,” Census tract by Census tract, Anna Falicov, director of the Bureau of Administrative Adjudication, told Investigative Post, so a district’s total depends partly on which tracts were reached this year.
By category, the largest is “interior access/enforcement,” at 1,590 violations. The report does not define the term. Next come smoke detectors (1,390), protective treatments (1,021), carbon monoxide (841), electrical (788) and interior surfaces (636). Unsafe or unfit structures numbered 46 and “occupancy prohibited” orders 50.

Zero warrants, and a state delay
In Exhibit One, the line “Number of Warrants DPIS Sought” reads zero for 2025, 2026 and to date. Petrucci’s report says that is “partially the result of Buffalo City Court issuing far fewer warrants as a matter of policy,” and that it “does not reflect the body of enforcement tools” DPIS uses, such as fines, tickets, postings and court cases. DPIS “can provide these numbers, if the Common Council would like,” the report adds. It calls enforcement “the cornerstone upon which the effort rests.”
The report also shows about $69,000 deposited in 2026 to an account labeled “T&A,” up from $1,875 in 2025 and $75 in 2024, and $425 withdrawn this year. It does not say what the account is or where the money came from. The Chronicle is asking.
A bigger obstacle may be in Albany. State health officials issued guidance in June that forbids “formal enforcement action” under the state’s new rental lead registry until 2029, Investigative Post reported in September. “It’s a huge disincentive,” Petrucci told the outlet. “How are we going to obtain compliance when the state pushed the goalpost down the road?”
Falicov said the delay means “landlords aren’t going to feel compelled to comply until December of 2028.” The Erie County Department of Health, which runs the state program locally, said in a statement that its “one primary concern” is that “enforcement will not happen until 2029,” leaving it unable to “enact fines or act to enforce, especially for persistent and blatant violators.”
On Oct. 28, 30 Western New York organizations led by the Partnership for the Public Good asked the state health commissioner to require immediate enforcement. “Between now and 2029, an estimated 800 children will be poisoned in the City of Buffalo alone,” their letter says. The state Department of Health told Investigative Post its 2023 law “proactively addresses lead hazards in rental homes.”
The courtroom and the landlord’s side
Advocates who sued the city in 2024 to force fuller enforcement lost in state Supreme Court and appealed. After oral argument on April 9, one of their lawyers, Matthew Parham of the Western New York Law Center, said the judges “seemed to understand that the city wasn’t complying with the letter of the law,” Buffalo Toronto Public Media reported. The Chronicle did not find a published appellate decision.
The program draws complaints from the other side too. Also before the Community Development Committee Tuesday is a September letter from a Delaware District homeowner to Councilmember Joel Feroleto objecting to “Showing up to my Resident for inspection unannounced” and saying the home had already been inspected for lead for Section 8. The program’s own materials say properties are scheduled for inspection and owners are notified by letter.
Who is accountable, and what to watch
Petrucci runs the program and controls the data in this report. The council can ask for more, and Tuesday’s committee meeting is the first chance since the report was filed. Mayor Sean Ryan ran on improving housing quality, according to BTPM, and the program is one of the city’s main tools for it.
The Chronicle’s questions for the committee, drawn from gaps in the report:
- How many inspected units passed on the first visit, failed, or are waiting on repairs?
- Does a certificate cover a property or a unit, and how long does it take to issue one?
- What is the “T&A” account, and what are the $69,000 in 2026 deposits?
- What does the department’s fuller enforcement data, which it offered to supply, show?
- How does DPIS plan to reach 30,000 units every three years at the current pace?
Related: Buffalo police overtime to cover minimum staffing jumped 65% in a year (Nov. 10).
Sources: Common Council packet, Nov. 10, 2026, item 26-000981, pp. 251–257; Community Development Committee agenda, Nov. 17; Investigative Post, Sept. 2, 2026; Partnership for the Public Good, Oct. 28, 2026; Buffalo Toronto Public Media, April 15, 2026; City of Buffalo Proactive Rental Inspections page. Featured photo: Sycamore Street on Buffalo’s Near East Side. Photo: Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.


















Leave a Reply