By Ruth Callahan
SALAMANCA — Tina Abrams took the oath as president of the Seneca Nation of Indians on Nov. 10, becoming the first woman elected to the Nation’s highest office, and used her first day to put New York State on notice. “She’s got a battle on her hands,” Abrams said of Gov. Kathy Hochul, according to Spectrum News, as the Nation and the state face new federal lawsuits over Seneca land in Buffalo and Grand Island and an expired gaming compact.
The governor’s office says it respects tribal sovereignty and is committed to a new compact. Abrams, who says she is willing to meet Hochul but not right away, begins a two-year term with both disputes unresolved and, as Spectrum put it, no clear timeline for settling either.
A historic oath
Abrams was sworn in at the Nation’s Canvass Day ceremony at Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino, along with the other candidates who won office in the Nov. 3 election, the Seneca Nation’s newsletter reported. Treasurer Lenith Waterman and Clerk Bethany Johnson were also sworn in, making the Nation’s executive branch all women for the first time. Eight new councilors, four each from the Allegany and Cattaraugus territories, joined the 16-member Council.
Abrams was first elected to the Council in 2001 and in 2012 became the first woman appointed its co-chair, according to the Nation. She spoke of the Seneca Clan Mothers who chose the Nation’s chiefs before the elected government was adopted in 1848, and of her grandfather, Morris Jimerson, and father, Walden Jimerson, who served on the Council and fought to give women the vote. Women won the right to vote in Nation elections in a 1964 referendum and the right to hold office in 1966.
“Now, the same little girl from Cattaraugus who used to go to meetings with her father and fall asleep in the Council House; a proud mother and grandmother who raised her family here in Allegany; and a longtime voice for the Seneca people on Council, will lead our Nation for the next two years,” she said. “I am honored beyond words to stand before you as your choice, your President, and as the first woman to receive and accept that responsibility.”

“Take the Indians’ land”
Her inaugural address named the history behind the present disputes. “We have to deal with hostile governments who want to take from us, but they don’t want to deal fairly with us,” Abrams said. “Outside leaders want to challenge our sovereignty without understanding or respecting our history. They want to force their laws upon us while they ignore our treaties, and, again, they want to take our land.”
“That is a lesson as old as the United States itself – take the Indians’ land. Take their way of life. Take their identity,” she said. “We have seen it at Buffalo Creek. We have seen it at Kinzua, and now they want to keep attacking, keep trying to get rid of us. They can try, but they will fail.” She closed by urging the Nation’s elected officials to remember that the day was a launch point, not the destination. “History will not judge us on the election that we won. It is the work that we do with the opportunity our people have given us that matters most.”
The lawsuits and the compact
The state filed two federal lawsuits four days before her inauguration, according to Spectrum. They challenge decisions by the U.S. Department of the Interior granting restricted fee status, a designation that gives federal protections to land, to Seneca Nation properties in Buffalo and Grand Island.
Abrams called the suits an attack. “It’s an attack on us. It’s an attack on our people. It’s an attack on our sovereignty. And we’re not going to put up with it. And I won’t either,” she said. She also questioned the timing while the two sides negotiate a compact: “She promises to negotiate a compact. And then the very next day, she sues us. So what is she thinking?”
Hochul’s office defended the lawsuits in a statement to Spectrum. “Governor Hochul is committed to a strong, productive relationship between the State and the Seneca Nation and she respects the principles of tribal sovereignty,” it said. “The governor also has an obligation to protect the interest of all Western New Yorkers, including ensuring that development in their communities follows appropriate laws and oversight.” The administration said it believes Interior wrongly qualified the properties for sovereignty status and expects the courts to agree.

The previous compact expired in 2023, and a new long-term deal governing the casinos and revenue sharing with the state has not been finalized, Spectrum reported. Last month, former President J.C. Seneca announced an agreement in principle that would eliminate revenue-sharing payments to New York. The governor’s office maintained that negotiations were ongoing. “The Governor remains committed to reaching a fair agreement that works for all parties on a new Gaming Compact with the Seneca Nation. Negotiations are ongoing,” the statement said.
Abrams was sharply critical of the state’s negotiators. “She relies on four guys, and they’re sort of a goon squad that keep coming to the table and keep emailing back and forth, and no progress is made,” she said. The governor’s office did not address those comments directly, according to Spectrum, and said: “We do not discuss details of ongoing litigation and negotiations.”
Buffalo and the Old First Ward
Abrams also took a position on a local dispute. WBEN reported that she supports the Seneca One Stop gas station and convenience store project in Buffalo’s Old First Ward, a roughly $10 million development on land with federal sovereign designation along Miami Street, and is upset with Mayor Sean Ryan, who opposes it. The city has challenged the federal land designation, according to Spectrum.
Asked whether she would meet Ryan, Abrams said: “I don’t have a reason to meet with Mayor Ryan. He’s another one that needs to educate himself.” She told WBEN she would be willing to meet Hochul, but only after preparation. “I’m willing to meet with her, but she has to do her homework first,” Abrams said. Spectrum reported that she first wants her new leadership team to get up to speed and reach a consensus with the Council on how to proceed.
WBEN reported that Rep. Tim Kennedy, a Buffalo Democrat, said he wants to meet Abrams and establish a relationship with her. Ryan has not indicated that he will meet with her soon, WBEN said. The accounts reviewed by the Chronicle did not include a comment from Ryan’s office on Abrams’ remarks.
What to watch
Seneca Nation presidents serve a single two-year term and the office alternates between the Allegany and Cattaraugus territories, WBEN reported. That gives Abrams two years to try to settle a compact and to answer the state’s lawsuits. The federal cases over the Buffalo and Grand Island parcels are pending; the sources reviewed by the Chronicle give no schedule for those cases or for the compact talks.
Featured photo: Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino, Salamanca, N.Y. Photo by Kurt Tarvis via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.
Sources: Seneca Nation of Indians, SNI Official Newsletter, Nov. 10, 2026; Spectrum News 1, Nov. 11, 2026; WBEN, Jim Fink.


















Leave a Reply