Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

Albany’s new Bureau of Comparable Hot Dogs sends frank sommeliers to Orchard Park to hunt for the legendary $9.69 hot dog

Satire: A state bill would cap Highmark Stadium’s $11.63 hot dog at 20% above “similar” hot dogs within 10 miles, so a fictional state bureau has sent frank sommeliers to find one. This column is parody, not a news report.

A ballpark hot dog with ketchup and mustard on a paper wrapper beside a cup of beer (photo: Navin75 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0)

Satire. This column is parody and is not a news report.

By Lyle Pennacott

ORCHARD PARK — New York State has opened a Bureau of Comparable Hot Dogs, and its first assignment is a manhunt. The quarry is a hot dog that sells for at least $9.69 somewhere within 10 miles of Highmark Stadium.

Nobody at the bureau has seen one. The bureau has been funded anyway, because that is how Albany shows it is serious.

The bureau is fictional. The arithmetic behind it is not. At a Nov. 10 Assembly hearing, a fans’ advocacy group said Highmark sells the most expensive hot dog in the NFL, at $11.63. A bill now parked in committee would cap food and soft-drink prices at publicly subsidized venues at 20 percent above the average price of “similar” items at “similar” businesses within 10 miles. Work backward from $11.63 and, as the Chronicle calculated, the neighborhood average would need to be about $9.69 for the stadium price to survive.

The exterior of the new Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park at dusk, reflected in a retention pond
Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park in October 2026. No hot dog sommeliers appear in this photo; they do not exist. Photo: Dekema via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The sommeliers fan out

“We have deployed 14 certified frank sommeliers along every road inside the radius,” said Thaddeus Pirog, the made-up acting deputy commissioner of the made-up bureau. “They have clipboards. They have tasting notes. Some of them have already gained eleven pounds.”

The sommeliers carry a 212-page field guide titled What Is a Similar Hot Dog? Chapter 1 asks whether a gas-station roller dog is “similar” to a stadium dog if both have been turning since roughly the second quarter. Chapter 2 is blank, pending a working group.

The real bill gives the job of defining “similar” to the Department of State, through audits and annual reports, without saying what “similar” means. The attorney general’s office told lawmakers that comparisons might sometimes have to be made even when an exact match is not possible. The bureau has framed that sentence and hung it over the mustard.

Albany takes its time

The real bill was referred to committee in July 2025 and again in January, and has not moved since. City & State reported it will need to be reintroduced in January.

In the fictional version, the bureau has adopted the same pace. Its first progress report is due when the hot dog is found. The hot dog will be found after the progress report.

“Albany has a long tradition of thinking very hard about Western New York for about one hearing,” said Mr. Pirog. “We are honoring that tradition with a strict 10-mile radius.”

The bill caps food and soft drinks. It does not cap beer. The bureau has asked the Legislature whether that was a policy decision or a scheduling decision. The Legislature has referred the question to committee.

The office towers of the Empire State Plaza in Albany, with the Cultural Education Center at the far end
The Empire State Plaza in Albany, which does not house a Bureau of Comparable Hot Dogs. Photo: Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The team, the county and the 6 percent

The Buffalo Bills did not answer WKBW when the station asked about concession prices. The bureau mailed the team a questionnaire on the same subject. It has not been answered either, which the bureau considers a comparable response.

Then there is the county. Every purchase at the stadium, hot dog included, carries a 6 percent Erie County surcharge under the lease. The money does not go to the county’s budget. Under the 2022 deal, it is “deemed the County’s contribution” to a capital fund for the stadium itself. The Bills sent Erie County nearly $2.9 million for August and September alone.

The bureau calls this the “circle of franks.” A fan buys a hot dog, and 6 percent goes to improving the building where fans buy hot dogs. The bureau requested a flowchart. It came back round.

Officials in Albany and Erie County celebrated the $850 million public share in 2022. The bureau has searched the footage for anyone asking what a hot dog would cost. The search continues, within a 10-mile radius.

What the real witnesses said

Brian Hess of the Sports Fans Coalition offered the committee an argument the bureau has since adopted as its motto. “Hot dogs don’t cost $12,” he said, according to WKBW. He also called high stadium prices “a monopoly wearing a jersey,” City & State reported.

The bureau has ordered the jersey in every size. It cost more than the hot dog.

As of press time, the sommeliers had covered 9.8 of the 10 miles and found a $4 hot dog, a $6 hot dog and no $9.69 hot dog. Mr. Pirog said the search would continue through the winter, or until the Legislature returns in January, whichever comes later.

This column is satire. The Bureau of Comparable Hot Dogs, Thaddeus Pirog, the frank sommeliers, the field guide, and the “circle of franks” are fictional. The $11.63 figure cited at the Nov. 10 hearing, the bill’s 20 percent and 10-mile terms, its status in committee, the beer exemption, the 6 percent surcharge and its use, and the quotes from Brian Hess as reported by WKBW and City & State are real; read the Buffalo Chronicle’s news report for the facts.

Featured image: a ballpark hot dog (not from Highmark Stadium) by Navin75 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0, cropped.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements