By Claire Whitcomb
WASHINGTON — House and Senate transportation leaders said Tuesday they have reached a bipartisan agreement in principle to require civilian aircraft already broadcasting their location to also receive those signals in the cockpit, nearly two years after an Army helicopter and a regional jet collided over the Potomac River and killed 67 people.
The deal, announced at a Capitol memorial organized by the Families of Flight 5342, settles the civil-aviation core of two competing bills. Military aircraft remain the unfinished fight. For Western New York, the moment sits in a long line of aviation-safety fights that began after Colgan Air Flight 3407 crashed in Clarence Center in 2009, and it comes a week after a nationwide ground stop left Buffalo travelers stranded.
What was agreed, and what was not
Senate Commerce Chairman Ted Cruz, R-Texas; Ranking Member Maria Cantwell, D-Wash.; House Transportation Chairman Sam Graves, R-Mo.; and Ranking Member Rick Larsen, D-Wash., said in a joint statement they had agreed on the civil aviation provisions of legislation that follows the National Transportation Safety Board’s recommendations after the Jan. 29, 2025, midair collision between American Airlines Flight 5342, operated by PSA Airlines, and a UH-60 Army Black Hawk near Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
“The Senate and House at long last have reached an agreement in principle to mandate ADS-B In for all flights that are required to broadcast ADS-B Out,” Cruz said Tuesday, according to WUSA9. Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast Out already sends an aircraft’s position. ADS-B In displays nearby traffic and can provide visual and audible alerts. The NTSB has recommended a requirement for nearly two decades; the Federal Aviation Administration has not adopted one.
“We reached an agreement with the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, in principle, on the civil aviation provisions of this legislation,” Cantwell said at the memorial. Speaking with Graves, she said, “we were able to reach a deal on ADS-B In, helicopter route operations, ADS-B Out, and fees.”
The lawmakers have been trying to reconcile two bills. The Senate in December 2025 passed S. 2503, the Rotorcraft Operations Transparency and Oversight Reform Act, or ROTOR Act, by unanimous consent. It would have required ADS-B In for commercial and military flights in busy airspace and narrowed military exemptions. The House in April passed H.R. 7613, the Airspace Location and Enhanced Risk Transparency Act, or ALERT Act, 396-10. That bill, the House committee said, would require ADS-B In and a corresponding collision-prevention technology on virtually all aircraft already required to have ADS-B Out, by Dec. 31, 2031, and would tighten military broadcasting on non-sensitive missions.

The military hitch that still has to be resolved
Cantwell was blunt that the civil deal is not a finished bill. “While we have a deal in principle on the civil provisions, we do not have an agreement on the military provisions,” she said. “We must have strong military accountability in the national airspace. The military must be a willing partner with the Department of Transportation and the FAA to make sure that what happened last January never, ever happens again.”
“When military aircraft operate in the same airspace, they must meet the same safety standards that protect everyone,” she said. “Allowing a military loophole for routine or training operations in that immediate area undermines the very safety provisions we have agreed upon.”
Cruz, speaking at the same event, said a few details remain with the House and Senate Armed Services Committees. “With this agreement in principle, I believe we’re going to get this bill done,” he said, according to CBS News. “And my objective is to get it done this year, with this Congress, before we leave for the new year.”
Graves, in the joint statement, said Congress “owes it to the victims and their families to get this safety legislation right.” He said the four leaders are “very close to a final agreement on the entire bill” and will keep working “to see a final House-Senate bill signed into law before the end of this Congress.” Larsen said the families’ “advocacy reminds us to always stay focused on improving aviation safety” and that, “due in no small part to their efforts, today we have announced an agreement in principle with the Senate on a requirement for ADS-B In.”
Why the House first rejected the Senate bill
The unfinished military piece is the same dispute that sank the ROTOR Act in the House on Feb. 24. Under suspension of the rules, which requires a two-thirds majority, the bill failed 264-133, one vote short, House Clerk records show. The Senate had already passed it unanimously. The day before the House vote, the Defense Department said the bill would “create significant unresolved budgetary burdens and operational security risks affecting national defense activities,” Roll Call reported. Graves and House Armed Services Chairman Mike Rogers, R-Ala., urged opposition on the floor.
NTSB Chairwoman Jennifer Homendy had backed the Senate bill and was in the House gallery with families that day. “The ROTOR Act would’ve saved lives; unlike claims that this is ‘emotional legislation,’ the FAA had over two decades to Act and failed to do so,” she wrote on X after the vote, Roll Call reported. “Had they acted, we wouldn’t be here today; families would have their loved ones. How many more people need to die before we Act?”
Cruz called the February result “just a temporary delay” and said “an overwhelming bipartisan majority of House lawmakers today made it abundantly clear that the ROTOR Act should pass and go to President Trump’s desk.” Graves, in a statement released before the result, committed to marking up the ALERT Act “as soon as next week” and said “safety will always be my number one priority.” The House passed that bill on April 14.
How Western New York’s members voted
The House Clerk’s roll call 72 records how the region voted when the Senate bill came up under suspension. Reps. Nick Langworthy (R-NY23); Tim Kennedy (D-NY26); and Joe Morelle (D-NY25) voted yea. Rep. Claudia Tenney (R-NY24) voted nay, joining 132 other Republicans. The only Democrat to vote no was Rep. Lizzie Fletcher of Texas, who said she was opposing bills brought under suspension.
On the ALERT Act in April, Langworthy, Tenney, Kennedy and Morelle all voted yea, roll call 110 shows. The bill passed 396-10. The House Transportation Committee said the measure “addresses all 50 of the NTSB’s final recommendations” and would require ADS-B In “by December 31, 2031.” Rogers said the bill “improves aviation safety without undermining our national security.” Ranking Member Adam Smith, D-Wash., called the January 2025 collision “100 percent preventable.”
The Chronicle is seeking comment from Langworthy, Tenney, Kennedy, Morelle, Graves, Cruz and the Defense Department on Tuesday’s agreement and on the unfinished military provisions.

Clarence Center, and a community that already wrote one aviation-safety law
Western New York’s connection to this fight is older than Flight 5342. On Feb. 12, 2009, Colgan Air Flight 3407, operating as Continental Connection, crashed on approach to Buffalo Niagara International Airport in Clarence Center, killing all 49 people on board and one person on the ground. The NTSB blamed pilot error and inadequate training. The families of those killed pressed Congress to pass the Airline Safety and Federal Aviation Administration Extension Act of 2010, which set the 1,500-hour commercial-pilot rule, new rest requirements and a pilot records database.
On the 17th anniversary in February, Kennedy and Langworthy introduced the Safe Flights for Passengers and Flight Crews Act, aimed at a loophole that lets some charter operators sell tickets for scheduled flights under less rigorous rules. “For Western New Yorkers, aviation safety is deeply personal, and our community has long led the fight to make our skies safer,” Kennedy said then. Langworthy, who chairs the Aviation Safety Caucus, said he was “proud to lead the fight to uphold the 1,500-hour rule in the FAA Reauthorization – standards born from the lessons of the tragic Colgan Flight 3407 disaster.”
The Families of Flight 3407 endorsed that bill. “PL111-216, ‘The Airline Safety and FAA Extension Act of 2010’, has proven to be a landmark aviation safety law,” the families said. “Over the past 15 years Charter airlines found a loophole in current FAA regulations that has permitted them to resume a second/ lesser level of aviation safety operations.”
Ron Aughtmon, who lost his uncle, John Fiore, on Flight 3407, told Spectrum News in February that the families were also watching the ROTOR Act after the Washington collision. The legislation had passed the Senate and was awaiting a House vote. “Aughtmon says there is a lot of confidence it will pass,” Spectrum reported. The House rejected it 12 days later.
The families at the Capitol, and what comes next
On Tuesday the Families of Flight 5342 formed the outline of an airplane around 67 empty chairs on the lawn below the Capitol, WUSA9 and ALPA reported, with three chairs, each holding a folded flag, in memory of the service members lost. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford attended, as did Homendy and Air Line Pilots Association President Capt. Jason Ambrosi.
Duffy praised the families for pushing Congress to pass new aviation safety laws and urged lawmakers to get the bills done, according to a report on his remarks. The administration’s Defense Department objections to the original Senate bill’s military requirements are what lawmakers now must work through with the Armed Services committees.
“This is the news the families of Flight 5342 have fought for,” Ambrosi said. “Twenty-two months after we lost 67 people over the Potomac, including two of our own, Congress is closer than ever to requiring the technology the National Transportation Safety Board found could have given our crew additional warning.” ALPA, he said, will keep pressing “to close the loophole that lets military aircraft fly through busy airspace, including around Washington National Airport, without broadcasting their position.”
Homendy told WUSA9 she was encouraged. “I think it’s going to get done with this Congress,” she said. Her message to lawmakers was personal: “I want them to think about their own families, their loved ones and how it would feel if they didn’t have them at the Thanksgiving table.” Chris Livingston, whose granddaughters Alydia and Everly and their parents, Peter and Donna, were on the flight, put it more sharply: “I try to be as polite as I can, but we sent you here to do a job … do it.”
Cantwell, closing her remarks, spoke directly to the families. “To the families, we know how long you’ve waited. It’s long enough. Let’s get this bill signed into law.”
The civil agreement is a framework, not enacted text, and the military provisions still have to be written with the Armed Services committees before a conference bill can reach the floor. The 119th Congress is in its lame-duck session; a new Congress, with Democrats in the House majority, convenes in January. Last week, after the longest nationwide ground stop in 25 years stranded Buffalo travelers, Duffy pressed Congress to fund air-traffic upgrades, as the Chronicle reported Nov. 15. Tuesday’s deal is a different fight — about what pilots can see in the cockpit, and whether military aircraft in shared airspace will be held to the same rule — but it is the same question Western New York has been asking since 2009: whether Congress will finish the work the families started.


















Leave a Reply