By Hannah Lindqvist
BUFFALO, N.Y. — Tanker trucks regularly haul garbage water from landfills across upstate New York to the Buffalo Sewer Authority’s Bird Island treatment plant. The plant treats it along with the city’s sewage and sends it out into the Niagara River.
That liquid is called leachate. It forms when rain and snowmelt seep through buried trash, and it can carry PFAS, the so-called forever chemicals. In July, the state Department of Environmental Conservation proposed what it called a first-in-the-nation rule: landfills would have to treat their leachate before it ever reaches a plant like Bird Island. Public comments closed Sept. 9. More than two months later, DEC’s regulations page still lists the rule as proposed, and the agency has not announced a final version.
How much comes to Buffalo
The numbers depend on who is counting, and they don’t always agree. A report released this summer by the advocacy group New York River Watch, built on public records requests, found that Bird Island sent out more than 47 million gallons of leachate a year from 2019 to 2023. That was the third-highest total of any sewage plant in the state, Buffalo Toronto Public Media reported.
Most of it comes from one place. The report found that Bird Island discharged 38.3 million gallons of leachate from Seneca Meadows, the state’s largest landfill, in the Finger Lakes town of Seneca Falls, according to the Finger Lakes Times. River Watch co-founder Rebecca Martin said the landfill shows “how a single landfill can spread contamination risks far beyond its host community.”
Buffalo Niagara Waterkeeper, citing the landfill’s own 2024 annual report, put the volume at more than 24 million gallons that year. In a 2023 investigation, WIVB-TV found the authority had earned at least $5.6 million over three years from haulers, in some contracts charging as little as 4 cents a gallon.

What the plant can and can’t do
Bird Island is built to break down sewage, not chemicals. A summary published by StreamGo, a treatment vendor that ran a pilot study for the authority, said the plant was taking 150,000 to 200,000 gallons of leachate a day from four landfills: Lewiston, Ontario County, Seneca Meadows and Chaffee. Baseline PFAS levels in those loads ranged from 58,000 to 110,000 parts per trillion. New York’s drinking water limit for PFOA and PFOS is 10 parts per trillion each.
The plant’s huge volume, about 150 million gallons a day, dilutes those concentrations. Critics say dilution is not removal.
“People often assume sewage treatment plants remove these contaminants because the term wastewater treatment plant suggests the waste is fully treated,” Jen Epstein, River Watch’s director of science, said, according to the Finger Lakes Times. “But these facilities were designed to handle domestic sewage, not the complex chemical mixtures found in landfill leachate.”
Jill Jedlicka, executive director of Buffalo Niagara Waterkeeper, made the same case in the group’s September comment letter to DEC. She wrote that the Niagara River below the plant is a Class A-Special drinking water source and that Bird Island’s biological treatment “is not set up to specifically remove PFAS.” A small PFAS filtration pilot at the plant, she wrote, “does not address the full volume of wastewater treated onsite.”
“No community should willingly import contaminated waste that it knows cannot be adequately treated,” Jedlicka wrote.
The authority’s side
The sewer authority has defended taking the waste. In 2023, O.J. McFoy, the authority’s general manager at the time, told WIVB that ending the practice might simply push the problem somewhere worse.
“Yes, we can, but I always offer this up: We’re doing our public health duty,” McFoy said. “If we’re not taking it, where is it going? Is it going into our rivers, lakes, and streams without any treatment? Where is it going to go?”
He also told the station it could cost about $100 million to add PFAS treatment at a plant the size of Bird Island, and said Buffalo ratepayers should not carry that bill.
The authority’s most recent annual report to DEC, filed in May, signals that its position may be shifting. “As PFAS regulations change and are incorporated into the BSA and landfill permits, we continue to evaluate the future of the acceptance of these wastes,” it said.

A rule that puts the job on landfills
DEC’s proposal would require active municipal and construction-debris landfills that collect leachate to treat it, including for PFAS and 1,4-dioxane, before sending it to a sewage plant. DEC Commissioner Amanda Lefton said in the agency’s July announcement that the rule would “maximize new technologies now available that effectively remove landfill pollutants for proper disposal.” The state has offered grants to help municipally owned landfills pay for treatment.
Landfill operators pushed back. The proposal would require 99.9% removal of a long list of contaminants and would give sewage plants four years to keep accepting leachate during the transition, Waste Dive reported. DEC estimated treatment systems could cost $3 million to $50 million each. “This is an extraordinarily expensive and wasteful approach to leachate management and a missed opportunity to develop a well-coordinated approach to PFAS,” Sam Nicolai, a vice president at Casella Waste Systems, said at a Sept. 2 hearing.
Waterkeeper wants the rule to go further. Its letter asks DEC to cover the more than 1,900 inactive landfills in the state, to hold out-of-state landfills to the same standard, and to require removal of every PFAS compound that EPA Method 1633 can measure.
Seneca Meadows, still waiting
The biggest supplier of Buffalo’s leachate is in regulatory limbo of its own. DEC has found Seneca Meadows’ proposed expansion application incomplete for a third time. A Sept. 21 notice asked for more detail on the landfill’s leachate treatment equipment, capacity and monitoring, Finger Lakes Daily News reported. “No further action can be taken until all of these materials are received,” DEC environmental analyst Ashley Kasperowicz said. The landfill’s air and solid waste permits have expired but remain in effect while DEC reviews them.
What comes next
The leachate rule is moving alongside a separate fight over drinking water. Advocates were at the Capitol on Monday urging Gov. Kathy Hochul to sign a bill, which cleared the Legislature unanimously this spring, that would lower the state’s limit for PFOA and PFOS to 4 parts per trillion by 2029, FingerLakes1 reported. The Buffalo Water Board, meanwhile, is suing 17 companies over PFAS in Lake Erie.
DEC has not said when it will finalize the leachate rule or whether it will change the 99.9% standard. Until it does, the trucks keep coming to Bird Island.
The Buffalo Chronicle has asked DEC and the Buffalo Sewer Authority for comment.


















Leave a Reply