Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

·

Savarino sues the NFTA over the DL&W Terminal as the agency seeks a new operator for the building’s rooftop deck

Developer Samuel Savarino says the NFTA had no authority to fire him from the DL&W Terminal project. The agency’s termination letter, filed with his complaint, says his plan relied on public subsidies its 2018 request for proposals ruled out.

An NFTA Metro Rail train parked beneath the former DL&W Terminal along South Park Avenue in Buffalo

By Elliot Brandt

BUFFALO — Developer Samuel Savarino has taken the Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority to court over the DL&W Terminal, saying the agency had no power to fire him from the project a year ago. He also says it can’t now look for someone else to program the building he still claims the exclusive right to develop. The 33-page filing, lodged Friday in State Supreme Court in Erie County, asks a judge to declare that his 2020 contract with the NFTA “remains in full force and effect.” It also seeks damages for what it calls an unconstitutional taking.

The NFTA’s side of the fight sits in the same court file. Its November 2025 termination letter, attached as an exhibit, says Savarino’s plan for the hulking second floor depended on tax credits and NFTA help. In the agency’s words, that amounted to “an enormous subsidy” that its original 2018 request for proposals ruled out. Three days before the suit was filed, the NFTA invited proposals from anyone who wants to run events on the building’s new rooftop Sky Deck. Savarino’s lawyers say that solicitation breaks his exclusivity. The two documents, and the 2020 agreement between them, show how a project announced with enthusiasm seven years ago ended up as a lawsuit.

What the lawsuit claims

The plaintiffs are Savarino Companies LLC and Savarino DL&W Development LLC, represented by Adam S. Walters and Jeremy M. Amar-Dolan of Phillips Lytle. The case was filed at 11:18 a.m. Nov. 13 under index number 823904/2026, according to the county clerk’s stamp on the complaint.

It lays out six claims: a taking of property without just compensation under Article I, Section 7 of the New York Constitution; deprivation of property without due process under Article I, Section 6; breach of contract; breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing; tortious interference with prospective business opportunities; and a request for a declaratory judgment. No dollar figure is demanded. Damages are left to be “determined at trial.”

“This action arises from the NFTA’s unlawful attempt to extinguish Plaintiffs’ valuable contractual and development rights in the redevelopment of the historic Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad Terminal,” the complaint begins.

Its central argument is procedural. The NFTA Board of Commissioners voted in December 2019 to authorize the pre-development agreement, the complaint says. It says the board “did not adopt a resolution authorizing termination” the same way, leaving the November 2025 letter from the agency’s outside counsel “void or voidable” under the state Public Authorities Law and a doctrine known as legislative equivalency. The suit also says Savarino was never given the written notice and chance to fix any problem that the contract requires before a breach-based termination.

The complaint puts Savarino’s spending at “at least $1.4 million” in project-specific costs before the termination. It lists architectural, design, tax-credit, legal, accounting, food-and-beverage, entertainment, sound-testing and placemaking work. It also says the firm signed letters of intent with two tenants: Buffalo Electric Glass, for about 14,000 square feet, and the CEPA Gallery, for about 6,000 square feet on a 10-year lease.

Aerial view of the DL&W (Lackawanna) Terminal and train shed along the Buffalo River in 1971
The DL&W Terminal and its train shed on the Buffalo River in 1971. (Photo: Jack Boucher, Historic American Engineering Record, Library of Congress, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain)

How the project got here

The documents agree on the early history. On Dec. 18, 2018, the NFTA issued Request for Proposal No. 4844 for the buildout and management of mixed-use space in the terminal at the foot of Main Street. Savarino Companies answered on March 12, 2019, and was the only respondent, the complaint says. The NFTA’s letter says the same. A nonbinding term sheet followed on Dec. 6, 2019, then the board’s Dec. 19 authorization, and then the pre-development agreement, signed July 17, 2020.

That agreement, attached to the complaint as Exhibit A, granted Savarino’s company “exclusive pre-development rights” to about 6,500 square feet on the first floor and about 130,000 square feet on the second, roughly 74,000 square feet indoors and 56,000 outdoors. The initial term was to run until 12 months after “substantial completion” of the NFTA’s new Metro Rail station in the building, with an option for one more year.

It also split the work. Under Section 4.1, the NFTA agreed to “commence and exercise commercially reasonable efforts to identify and secure financial support” for improvements to the core and shell of the space, which the agreement calls Owner Improvements. Section 4.2 said the agency would work toward substantial completion of the station by Dec. 31, 2023. In Section 7.1, both sides acknowledged that the money for those improvements “has not been secured” and that getting it would be “challenging” during the COVID-19 pandemic.

In a June update to investors posted under the name Savarino Properties, the company wrote that its original proposal called for a 20-year lease at $1 a year with three 10-year extensions, and that it later offered the NFTA 25% of net operating revenue. The update says the NFTA “accepted Savarino’s proposal with enthusiasm.”

Where the money went

The complaint says the NFTA, with Savarino’s help, won a $30 million commitment from Empire State Development for those core-and-shell improvements. It says Savarino then “materially increased” its own spending, only to learn that the agency planned to put “substantial portions” of the state money toward other work. “In sum, the NFTA failed to cooperate in good faith to advance the Project,” the complaint says.

The Buffalo News, which reported the lawsuit Monday, wrote that the NFTA has spent $57 million on the building so far. The News reported that cost overruns and unexpected repairs and stabilization meant there was not enough left for heating and ventilation, electrical work, flooring and bathrooms on the second floor.

The transit work did get done. The DL&W station opened as the first extension of Metro Rail since 1985, and the Chronicle reported Nov. 3 that it had been closed since Nov. 1 while the city’s Cars Sharing Main Street work catches up. The NFTA said at the time that it would stay closed until that phase is finished.

The Metro Rail boarding platform inside the DL&W Station in Buffalo, with a train at the far end
The Metro Rail platform inside DL&W Station in December 2025. (Photo: Dekema via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

The NFTA’s reasons

The termination letter, dated Nov. 14, 2025, comes from Daniel A. Spitzer, a partner at Hodgson Russ, and is addressed to Walters. It cites two parts of the agreement’s termination clause that, the letter says, “does not require a notice or cure period.”

The first is Section 7.4(c), which lets the NFTA end the deal if information in Savarino’s proposal is “determined to be false or misleading in any material respect.” The letter says the 2019 proposal never described a project that depended on historic and new markets tax credits, “which is the only structure Developer now claims will allow the Project to proceed.” It says the proposal certified that the developer had the financial wherewithal to finish the work, a claim the letter calls “now false and misleading in a material respect.”

The second is Section 7.4(d), noncompliance with the request for proposals. The letter says the RFP required the respondent itself to show bonding capacity. It says Savarino’s tax-credit counsel told the NFTA’s lawyers in a March 2025 memo that bonding would come from the project’s general contractor. It also quotes the RFP’s bar on financial plans that assume “any form of State and/or other agency funding assistance” beyond generally available programs. “In other words, the NFTA will not subsidize the Project,” Spitzer wrote.

By the letter’s account, Savarino’s tax-credit structure called for a 75-year ground lease of the property to the developer at $1 a year. The NFTA would lease its own train station back at market rent for 25 years and then buy it back at market value. The letter quotes a May 23, 2023, email in which Savarino wrote that the “NFTA will be a leverage lender to an investment fund that is necessary to generate the NMTC subsidy.” A footnote acknowledges that Savarino “has recognized the flaw in the $1 annual rent and discussed paying fair market value rent,” but says no pro forma was ever submitted.

A third ground addresses publicity. The agreement’s Section 9 says press releases and public statements about the project “shall be jointly developed and agreed upon by the parties.” The letter says Savarino issued statements to media outlets and posted updates online without the NFTA’s consent. It concedes that Section 7.4(a) gives the developer 30 days to cure a breach of the agreement, but argues that notice “would be futile and, therefore, inapplicable because the breach cannot be remedied once the statements are publicly issued.”

An earlier letter, sent Oct. 22, 2025, was obtained separately by the News. In it, Spitzer wrote that a project “mini-model” showed that “the tax credit and public contributions are the entire sources of capital for the project.” “This admission is both stunning and infuriating,” Spitzer wrote, according to the News. “The developer plainly lacks the ability to comply with its continuing obligations under the RFP.”

Savarino’s lawyers answer

Savarino Companies declined to comment on the lawsuit. “I can’t comment, as we are bound by the PDA not to talk to the media,” Christa Glennie of Savarino Companies said in an email to The Buffalo Chronicle, referring to the pre-development agreement. She shared a letter Walters sent Spitzer on Nov. 14, 2025, the same date as the termination letter, answering the NFTA’s October letter.

The letter says the October letter “continues the disturbing trend of misrepresenting basic facts and agreements.” It argues that the 2018 request for proposals no longer governs the relationship, because the agreement “supersedes any prior understandings and agreements,” and that the agreement stays in force “whether or not the parties are able to successfully negotiate and execute the Additional Agreements.”

On financing, Walters wrote that “it is common for developers to rely on tax credits as the source of equity in a development project when such credits are available,” and that the developer had spent “hundreds of thousands of its own dollars trying to move the Project forward.” He wrote that the developer applied for and obtained historic tax credits, which he said the RFP allows. Because the NFTA would have to create a for-profit subsidiary to use the credits itself, which the letter says it is not empowered to do, Walters argued that providing them to the developer “in no way amounts to a financial subsidy from the NFTA.”

The letter rejects the publicity complaint. It says Buffalo Rising articles drawn from the developer’s website and social media are “NOT the Developer issuing press releases, public announcements or talking to the media,” and accuses the NFTA of breaking the same clause when its executive director gave interviews to the Buffalo Business Journal and WBEN in August 2025 without consulting the developer. It says Savarino “has clearly and loudly objected” to the NFTA spending the $30 million from Empire State Development on work other than the Owner Improvements, and that the developer was preparing “an updated, comprehensive proposal” with a simplified structure.

The letter closes by noting the termination letter that arrived the same day. “The fact that the NFTA is purportedly terminating the PDA without even giving the Developer a chance to respond to the October HR Letter smacks at the kind of bad faith the NFTA has engaged in over the course of the last year,” Walters wrote. “We also note that it appears that this action has not been authorized by the NFTA Board of Commissioners.”

What the contract says about cure

The copy of the agreement attached to the complaint lists five grounds for termination by the NFTA under Section 7.4. Only the first, “any breach by Developer of this Agreement,” comes with the 30-day cure window after written notice. The others cover false representations, misleading proposal information, RFP noncompliance and bankruptcy, and none of them mentions a cure period. The NFTA’s letter relies on two of those other grounds. Savarino’s complaint says the reasons given were “pretextual” and that the cure protection applied anyway.

The agreement also gave the NFTA a separate exit. Section 7.2 let the agency end the deal “for convenience, without penalty or liability” within 90 days after receiving the final report from Project for Public Spaces, the planning consultant Savarino hired. The November 2025 letter does not invoke that clause.

Whether the board needed to vote is a question for the court. The termination letter, as filed, does not mention a board vote either way.

The DL&W Terminal lit at dusk behind fencing and a newly paved path during construction in August 2025
Construction around the DL&W Terminal in August 2025. (Photo: Dekema via Wikimedia Commons, CC0)

The NFTA’s response

The NFTA declined to comment on the litigation, the News reported, but said in an emailed statement that the facts “have been grossly distorted and twisted.” “The NFTA acted in good faith for many years, worked rigorously to successfully build the DL&W rail station, and renovated this historic building,” the agency said, according to the News. “The NFTA will continue its commitment and hard work to provide our community with access to the DL&W for all to experience and enjoy.”

Savarino’s company answered in a Nov. 16 post addressed to partners, vendors, investors and tenants. “We will not walk away from the DL&W Terminal Project,” the post says. “We have taken this step to protect our development rights, your hard work, our collective work product, and our shared commitment to a project we have been working on together for 7+ years.”

A new solicitation for the Sky Deck

On Nov. 10, the NFTA opened Request for Proposal No. 260065, seeking a “Public Space Manager” to “develop and manage public programming and events” at DL&W Station. The winner would get a three-year license with two one-year options. A pre-proposal conference and site inspection are set for 11 a.m. Wednesday, Nov. 18. Questions are due Nov. 19, and proposals close Dec. 10.

The focus is the Sky Deck, which the RFP describes as about 43,700 square feet of outdoor space over the Buffalo River with a current maximum occupancy of 1,500, rising to 3,000 in fall 2027. Respondents may also propose events for the Riverview Platform, about 6,690 square feet on the first floor along the Shoreline Trail. Proposals that cover only the platform will be rejected as unresponsive.

Both spaces sound a lot like what Savarino’s agreement covered: outdoor space on the second floor and, according to his June update, a 6,500-square-foot piece of the first floor along the Shoreline Trail. Neither the RFP nor the complaint says whether the footprints are identical. The figures also vary within the NFTA’s own materials. When the Sky Deck opened Oct. 1, the agency’s announcement called it “approximately 55,000 square feet” able to “support events for over 2,100 people.”

“The DL&W is an important part of Buffalo’s history, and the Sky Deck gives people an entirely new way to experience this remarkable building and its waterfront setting,” NFTA Executive Director Kim Minkel said at the ribbon cutting, according to the agency.

The state’s bigger plan

The suit lands as the state starts planning the district around the terminal. On Monday, Gov. Kathy Hochul announced public workshops for “Canalside: The Next Wave,” a decade-long strategy led by Empire State Development and the design firm MKSK. Its study area runs from the Erie Basin Marina to Michigan Avenue, which takes in the DL&W. The governor’s release lists “the grand opening of the NFTA’s DL&W Terminal facility” among the district’s recent investments. It does not mention the second floor or the dispute.

An in-person session is set for 5 to 7:30 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19, at the 1970 Club inside KeyBank Center, with a virtual presentation at noon Friday, Nov. 20, and a second online survey launching the same day at buffalowaterfront.com.

“To maximize three-quarters of a billion dollars in previous state investments, ESD is excited to bring the necessary expertise to Buffalo’s waterfront and turn urban plans into concrete results,” ESD President and CEO Hope Knight said in the release.

Who decides, and what could settle it

The case puts three sets of decisions in front of the public. The first belongs to the court. Savarino’s declaratory-judgment claim asks a judge to say whether the agreement still exists, and the answer will shape everything else, including whether the Sky Deck license can be awarded cleanly. The NFTA has 20 days to answer after personal service, or 30 if service is completed another way, under the summons.

The second belongs to the NFTA Board of Commissioners. The complaint’s main procedural argument is that the board approved the deal by resolution and never voted to end it. A board vote taken in public, either ratifying the termination or reopening talks, would put the authority’s position on the record whichever way it goes.

The third concerns money. The core dispute is who pays to make 130,000 square feet of a century-old train shed usable. The NFTA says it can’t give up control of a working transit station or subsidize a private developer. Savarino says the agency spent the state’s $30 million on other work and then faulted him for not having a business plan. Neither side has published the full financial model at issue. Both the termination letter and the News account describe it only in pieces.

The Chronicle is seeking comment from the NFTA on the lawsuit, the board’s role and the overlap between the new RFP and the 2020 agreement. This report will be updated with any response.

Sources: Savarino Companies, LLC v. Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority, Index No. 823904/2026, summons, complaint and exhibits (Erie County Supreme Court, filed Nov. 13, 2026); NFTA RFP 260065, Project Scope and Technical Specifications (Nov. 10, 2026); Phillips Lytle letter to Hodgson Russ, Nov. 14, 2025, provided by Savarino Companies; Savarino Properties, Nov. 16, 2026; Savarino Properties, June 24, 2026; The Buffalo News, Nov. 16, 2026; NFTA, Sky Deck ribbon cutting; Office of Gov. Kathy Hochul, Nov. 16, 2026. Featured photo: an NFTA Metro Rail train at the former DL&W Terminal, by Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.

Updated November 17, 2026: This story was updated to include a response from Savarino Companies and its attorneys’ November 2025 letter to the NFTA’s counsel.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements