Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

Betty’s, 22 years on, is a daytime kitchen where the vegan menu runs as deep as the Benedicts

Our reported Food column looks at Betty’s, the Allentown corner restaurant now serving breakfast, lunch and brunch only: its menu and prices, its owner’s and chef’s own words, a spotless inspection record and what diners say. No visit, just the record.

Betty's, a two-story red brick corner restaurant with a green and white oval sign and a striped awning over its patio, beside a large willow tree at Virginia and Cottage streets in Buffalo's Allentown neighborhood (Photo: G. Edward Johnson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

By Angela Russo

BUFFALO, N.Y. — Betty’s has occupied the red brick corner of Virginia and Cottage streets since October 2004, long enough that a lot of Buffalonians can’t picture the edge of Allentown without it. Twenty-two years later, Betty’s is a daytime restaurant. Its website lists breakfast, lunch and weekend brunch, and says dinner is “closed temporarily.”

This column isn’t based on a visit, and nobody from The Chronicle ate there for this piece. It draws on the menus and prices posted on the restaurant’s website, its owners’ and chef’s on-the-record interviews with Buffalo Business First and WKBW, Buffalo Spree’s coverage, Erie County Department of Health inspection records, and a read of public diner ratings.

A tribute to a mother, in a former hardware store

The restaurant’s own history page traces the building back to at least 1874. Over the years it held a shoe repair shop, a grocer, Lomascola Hardware from 1950 to 1970, and a string of delis. It sat vacant from 1987 to 1990, after the county took it in foreclosure. Carroll Ann Simon bought it in October 2003 and redeveloped it with co-owner Doty Hall. They named it for Hall’s mother, “a tribute to mothers everywhere,” the site says.

The restaurant’s homepage still describes the idea in plain terms: food that is “simple, fresh, and creative, drawing on American and international influences,” served in “a cheerful, sunny dining room” by a “friendly and funky staff.” Buffalo Spree summed up the result in a January 2023 roundup: “A Buffalo institution, Betty’s has been feeding locals homey, fresh fare since 2004.”

Simon and Hall have since sold the business and moved to Youngstown, Buffalo Rising reported in 2023. The current owner, Arber Sopi, took over about five years before Buffalo Business First profiled him in April 2023, and he told the paper he set out to change as little as possible.

“My goal was not to come in and just blow things up. My plan was to come in as quietly as possible and just continue things,” Sopi told Business First’s Tracey Drury.

The Virginia Street entrance of Betty's, a red brick building with green and red striped awnings, a Betty's sign over an accessible ramp, potted flowers and an American flag
Betty’s Virginia Street entrance, with its ramp and striped awnings, in September 2025. (Photo: G. Edward Johnson / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

What’s on the menu

The breakfast and lunch menu posted on the site runs from a $5 broiled grapefruit and a $10 classic breakfast of two eggs, home fries and toast to $16 shrimp and grits topped with jalapeños. Biscuits with chorizo gravy are $15. A breakfast burrito with black beans and peppers is $14, and carnitas con huevos, slow-roasted pork with salsa verde over corn tortillas, is $14.

The weekend brunch menu adds a $13 chilaquiles casserole, eggs Benedict at $14, a smoked salmon version at $16 and a portobello Benedict at $13. Lunch salads run $7 to $16, and sandwiches, served with soup or salad, run $12 to $16 for the 8-ounce Betty Burger.

What sets the menu apart is how much of it is built for people who don’t eat meat, without being a vegetarian restaurant. Items are marked vegan, vegetarian or gluten-free throughout. There’s a scrambled tofu hash with sweet potatoes and black beans ($13), a vegan spanakopita ($13), house-made seitan “Chick’n Wyngz” ($13) and a Beefless Weck ($15), described as “a vegan version of a Buffalo classic,” thinly sliced seitan on a kimmelweck roll with horseradish aioli. There’s even a $9 “For Fido” section of unseasoned grilled chicken, salmon or tuna for dogs.

A note of caution: the menus say prices are “subject to change without notice,” and some of the posted files are labeled 2021, so call ahead to confirm current prices.

“That’s not what we believe in”

The kitchen’s scratch-cooking philosophy has been on the record for years. In 2019, then-head chef Kujo Kumro, who is vegan and had built out much of the plant-based menu, told WKBW that rising costs wouldn’t change how the food is made.

“If we have to raise the prices because we have to keep our morals in the kitchen….we could easily buy products that are already pre-made and use them, but it’s just — that’s not what we believe in,” Kumro said.

He was candid that customers had noticed. “We did just recently get a review where they said the prices were a tad high,” he said. Sopi told the station he worried about the servers: “The prices will go up and people won’t be tipping like they used to,” he said.

The Chronicle could not confirm who leads the kitchen today and is seeking comment from the restaurant.

What diners say

The public ratings are steady and good. Yelp’s listing showed 4.1 stars from 807 reviews in search results on Nov. 17, 2026. Restaurantji, which compiles Google ratings, showed 4.4 across 444 ratings as of its Nov. 14 update, and Betty’s Facebook page listed 4.4 from 1,827 reviews. On Yelp, the dishes reviewers mention most are the eggs Benedict, the breakfast burrito and the French toast casserole.

The praise in public summaries centers on the vegan and gluten-free range, the rotating local art on the walls and a dog-friendly patio. The complaints are about time. A review summary on the travel site Airial notes that “some diners have experienced slow service and potential issues with new staff, and weekend waits can be significant due to their no-reservation policy.” The restaurant’s reservations page confirms it takes no brunch reservations and seats parties only when everyone has arrived.

The inspection record

Betty’s is inspected by the Erie County Department of Health, which posts results online. Its three most recent routine inspections, on Feb. 25, 2025, Jan. 7, 2026 and July 17, 2026, each recorded zero critical and zero non-critical violations. Critical violations are the ones more likely to contribute to foodborne illness, such as improper food temperatures.

A row of brick storefront bars and restaurants with hanging signs along a sunny sidewalk on Allen Street in Buffalo's Allentown neighborhood
Allen Street’s row of bars and restaurants, a few blocks from Betty’s, in 2015. (Photo: Andre Carrotflower / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0)

The verdict

Betty’s is for a weekday breakfast meeting, a long weekend brunch, or a table where one person wants chorizo gravy and another is vegan or gluten-free. Most plates on the posted menus are $16 or less, the ratings have held up across hundreds of reviews, and its recent inspection record is spotless.

What stands out is the depth of the plant-based menu, which goes well past a token veggie burger to a seitan weck and tofu hash. What to expect: a weekend wait, a no-reservations policy for brunch and a pace some reviewers call slow. It isn’t a dinner option right now. Its website lists MasterCard, Visa, Discover and cash, so don’t count on American Express.

If you go

Betty’s
370 Virginia St., Buffalo, NY 14201
(716) 362-0633 · bettysbuffalo.com

Hours (as listed by the restaurant): Closed Mondays. Breakfast Tuesday–Friday 8 a.m.–3 p.m.; lunch Tuesday–Friday 11 a.m.–3 p.m.; brunch Saturday 9 a.m.–3 p.m. and Sunday 9 a.m.–2 p.m. Dinner is “closed temporarily.”

Price range: The restaurant describes its cuisine as “moderately priced.” Posted menus run $5–$16 for breakfast and brunch plates and $7–$16 for lunch salads and sandwiches; prices are subject to change.

Reservations: By phone only, for parties of five or more at weekday breakfast and lunch. No brunch reservations.

This is a reported column. The Buffalo Chronicle did not dine at Betty’s for this piece.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements