By Simon Achterberg
BUFFALO, N.Y. — The people asking the city to make landmarks of four aging buildings on Broadway are not their owners, a neighborhood group or a preservation nonprofit. The applicant listed on each form is the city’s own Preservation Board.
The board was scheduled to hold public hearings Thursday on designating the Kolipinski Building at 1119 Broadway, the Dzimian Building at 1131 Broadway, the Szymanski Building at 1159 Broadway and Public School 44, the former Lincoln School, at 1349 Broadway, all in the Broadway-Fillmore neighborhood, according to the Nov. 12 agenda and meeting packet. A fifth hearing, on the city-owned Broadway Barns at 201 Broadway, came from Preservation Buffalo Niagara.
Each of the four board-filed applications, dated between July 15 and Oct. 21, marks the same answer to two questions on the city’s form: whether the owner knows about the application, and whether the owner supports it. Both are checked “Unknown.” The form asks applicants who answer that way to “please include a summary of outreach efforts.” The Buffalo Chronicle did not find one in the published application files.
As of Sunday morning, the city had posted no minutes or results from Thursday’s hearings.
What the board says is worth saving
The applications, which run to dozens of pages of history, photographs and old newspaper clippings, make a detailed case for each building.
The Szymanski Building went up in 1922 for grocer Bolesław Szymański and was designed by architect Joseph Zakrzewski, according to its application. Its upper floor housed a Polish Army veterans’ post from 1928 and later the Buffalo Veterans Hall, and an Off-Track Betting parlor took over the storefront in 1984. The storefront glass is now covered with plywood. The application calls the building “a tangible reminder of Broadway’s historic importance as the commercial and cultural heart of Buffalo’s Polish-American community.”
The Dzimian Building, built in 1931 for wallpaper and paint merchant Sylvester A. Dzimian at Broadway and Warren Avenue, gets the strongest language. Its application describes it as “an unusually intact and sophisticated example of the early twentieth-century two-part commercial block,” with pale terra cotta, basketweave brick and leaded-glass transoms.
The Kolipinski Building, a 1920 department store at Broadway and Sweet Avenue, later spent 47 years as Kolipinski Brothers Furniture. Its application calls it “a visually prominent contributor to the historic commercial streetscape of Broadway,” while noting that the storefront “has been extensively altered and obscured by modern materials.”

Public School 44 is a different case. It was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2018, and its application says the long-vacant building “is poised for adaptive reuse” as affordable apartments financed in part with historic tax credits. Developer SAA Canopy Group says the project will create 77 affordable homes, including 12 new townhomes on nearby vacant lots, with half reserved for victims of domestic violence. The project already has to meet federal rehabilitation standards to get those credits. A local designation would add city review of exterior work.
What designation means for an owner
Designation is not ceremonial. The Preservation Board “reviews all exterior work to properties designated as local landmarks or located within local historic districts,” according to the city’s website. The board recommends, and the Common Council decides.
Those tradeoffs came up in Broadway-Fillmore before. When the board backed the neighborhood’s 244-building historic district in 2018, Jeff Jones of 716 Ministries warned that poor residents would face a tough process. “I don’t think that many of them understand how it’s going to work and safe to navigate the Preservation Board,” he told WBFO, now Buffalo Toronto Public Media. The Council adopted the district that May.
Supporters argued then that designation opens the door to state and federal historic tax credits for owners who rehabilitate. The four new applications do not say whether any owner has sought that help or plans to.
The owners listed are Burmese House Inc. for the Kolipinski Building, Sadia & Nisa LLC for the Dzimian Building, Daleelussalaam, Inc. for the Szymanski Building, and 44 Apartments Housing Development Fund Corp. for the school. None of the four is marked endangered.

An earlier test is stuck at City Hall
The Council is already weighing one of these board-initiated nominations, and it has not gone smoothly.
In March the Preservation Board filed to landmark 756 Broadway, an 1894 store-and-apartment building near Fox Street that once housed Stransky’s Hardware. That application also lists the owner’s awareness and support as unknown, and says the owner is a company with a Brooklyn mailing address. It marks the building endangered and says it has been vacant since about 1995, calling it “an increasingly rare remnant of the historic streetscape along Broadway.”
The Council’s Legislation Committee voted Nov. 4 to recommend denial, according to its minutes. At the full Council meeting on Nov. 10, the item was recommitted to the committee, and it is back on the committee’s Nov. 17 agenda.
It is not the only landmark item sitting in committee. The Nov. 4 minutes show proposals for 654 William Street and the Allied Mills complex on the Buffalo River tabled again. Three more nominations, for Public School 51, the St. Casimir social center and school, and the fireboat Edward M. Cotter, were sent to the committee on Nov. 10.
The building the city wants gone
The Broadway Barns hearing shows the limits of the process. The city owns the former arsenal and armory, parts of which date to 1858, and its own deputy mayor has said it is likely coming down. After concrete panels fell inside this fall, Deputy Mayor Ben Swanekamp told Buffalo Toronto Public Media, “Historical or not, I don’t know what it would take to make that building stabilized and safe.” Asked if demolition would follow, he said, “speaking bluntly, probably, yeah.” (The Buffalo Chronicle reported on the Barns in October.)
That leaves a few questions the public record does not answer. Did the board or its staff contact the owners of the four Broadway buildings before Thursday? Did any owner speak at the hearing, and did the board vote? And if the Council balks at 756 Broadway, a vacant building its own application calls endangered, what does that mean for four buildings no one has marked endangered at all?
The Buffalo Chronicle is asking the Preservation Board’s staff about Thursday’s hearings and owner outreach, and will update this story with any response.


















Leave a Reply