Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

· ·

Supreme Court will hear the Trump administration’s case to suspend asylum at the southern border

The justices agreed Friday to review a D.C. Circuit ruling that the January 2025 proclamation and Homeland Security guidance went beyond the president’s power. The restrictions remain in effect while the court hears the case.

The west facade of the U.S. Supreme Court Building in Washington at dusk

By Claire Whitcomb

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday agreed to decide whether the Trump administration may suspend access to asylum for immigrants at the U.S.-Mexico border, adding a central piece of the president’s immigration policy to a docket that will be argued early next year and decided by June.

The case is Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services. It stems from a Jan. 20, 2025, proclamation in which President Donald Trump declared that “an invasion is ongoing at the southern border” and suspended the entry of noncitizens “engaged in the invasion,” SCOTUSblog’s Amy Howe reported. The Department of Homeland Security then issued guidance that, among other things, barred noncitizens from applying for asylum and provided for rapid removal with fewer of the procedural protections in federal law.

The justices granted review of two questions, according to the court’s order: whether the proclamation and guidance are lawful, and whether a federal statute bars the classwide relief a district judge entered. They declined to take up a third question about whether the class itself was properly defined.

The administration’s case

Solicitor General D. John Sauer told the court that the policy is at the center of the president’s border response. “Suspending the illegal entry of aliens and precluding their access to asylum” is “[t]he most important and effective pieces of the President’s response,” Sauer wrote, as quoted by SCOTUSblog. Trump’s lawyers also described the January 2025 policy as his “single most effective policy” in ending chaos along the border, the Los Angeles Times reported.

“Over preceding four years, at least eight million illegal aliens were encountered along the southern border,” Sauer told the court, “and countless millions more evaded detection and illegally entered the United States.” The numbers, he said, had “overwhelmed the system,” making it impossible for officials to screen and interview asylum seekers. Lacking detention space, most were released into the country, the Times reported.

In the government’s telling, the proclamation “rests on a commonsense understanding of the President’s inherent and delegated powers to exclude aliens.” Sauer said Trump “acted well within his authority in preemptively indicating that asylum applications filed by aliens who violate the proclamation’s entry suspension would be denied—and in effectuating that discretionary policy choice by directing that the government need not accept futile asylum applications from those aliens.”

Federal immigration law does give the president broad power to suspend entry. It says he “may by proclamation, and for such period as he shall deem necessary, suspend the entry of all aliens or any class of aliens as immigrants or nonimmigrants, or impose on the entry of aliens any restrictions he may deem to be appropriate.” Sauer also argues that a separate provision of immigration law bars lower courts from issuing classwide orders that require officials to keep accepting asylum claims and hearings before expedited removal.

CBP Commissioner Rodney S. Scott tours the U.S.-Mexico border wall near San Diego
U.S. Customs and Border Protection Commissioner Rodney S. Scott tours the border wall near San Diego on Aug. 18, 2025. (Photo: Jaime Rodriguez / CBP, public domain)

What the lower courts held

U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss recognized a class of immigrants who are or would be subject to the proclamation, struck down the DHS guidance, and barred officials from carrying it out. A D.C. Circuit panel later largely agreed.

Judge J. Michelle Childs, joined by Judge Cornelia Pillard, wrote that the “text, structure, and history” of federal immigration law “make clear that in supplying power to suspend entry by Presidential proclamation, Congress did not intend to grant the Executive the expansive removal authority it asserts. The Proclamation and Guidance are thus unlawful to the extent that they circumvent … removal procedures and cast aside federal laws affording individuals the right to apply and be considered for asylum or withholding of removal protections.”

Judge Justin Walker dissented in part. He argued that the president has discretion to deny all asylum applications and can therefore dispense with the application process, but he agreed that the government “cannot remove aliens to countries where they will be persecuted, and the Proclamation and Guidance cannot strip them of mandatory procedures that protect against that removal.”

The D.C. Circuit kept its ruling on hold while the government appealed, so the asylum restrictions have remained in effect pending the Supreme Court’s review.

President Donald Trump at the Resolute Desk with a stack of executive orders as reporters look on
President Donald Trump in the Oval Office with a stack of executive orders. The Jan. 20, 2025, proclamation is the starting point of the case the court agreed to hear. (Photo: The White House, public domain)

The challengers’ case

The challengers told the justices the D.C. Circuit “correctly held that the President may not invent by fiat a new removal system that eviscerates the protections Congress mandated by statute.” They also disputed the administration’s description of an “unprecedented crisis,” writing that “the facts say otherwise. By January 2025, before the Proclamation took effect, border apprehensions had returned to historically routine levels, down over 90 percent from their peak. If the Executive Branch nonetheless believes it needs new tools to manage the border, Congress must provide them.”

Federal law, they wrote, “provides that noncitizens ‘may apply’ for asylum, ‘irrespective of … status’” or how they entered. “In conflict with statutory command,” they said, “the Proclamation and Guidance dictate that statutorily eligible noncitizens may not apply for or receive asylum.”

“The president does not have the right to unilaterally override the protections Congress has afforded those fleeing danger,” said Lee Gelernt, lead counsel and deputy director of the ACLU’s Immigrants’ Rights Project, in a statement also quoted by the Times. “The courts are right to reject this unprecedented power grab that would put countless lives in danger. We look forward to making our case before the Supreme Court.”

The ACLU statement is the organization’s characterization of the lower-court rulings; those courts did block the policy, and that block has been stayed while the justices hear the appeal.

Keren Zwick, executive director of the National Immigrant Justice Center, said the plaintiffs “fled persecution and torture, including political imprisonment and threats from the Taliban. Yet, the Trump administration refused to honor its obligation to consider them for asylum.” Some, she said, “were removed to third countries and then pushed back to the very place they fled.”

The court will hear argument early next year and is expected to rule by June. In the meantime, the proclamation and guidance remain in force under the stay.

Featured photo: The west facade of the U.S. Supreme Court Building in Washington at dusk. Photo by Joe Ravi via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0, cropped.

Sources: SCOTUSblog, Amy Howe, Nov. 13, 2026; the court’s Nov. 13 order in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center, No. 26-239; Los Angeles Times, David G. Savage, Nov. 13, 2026; ACLU and partner statements quoted in that coverage.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements