By Ray Dombrowski
BUFFALO — Erie County is funding a one-year, $500,000 pilot to put mental health clinicians back with the Buffalo Police Department’s Behavioral Health Team, as county and city partners described a co-response model they say is still being built.
Police Commissioner Erika Shields told a Crisis to Care Collaborative panel on Thursday that the work for law enforcement turns on going out with clinicians, not just sending officers alone. “I think what’s really key is that we build out a successful co-response model, so that when available, that we have caseworkers going out with us, so that we have people who this is this is all they do, is and we can lean on their expertise to handle the call as effectively as possible,” Shields told Buffalo Toronto Public Media.
The wording is inelegant, but the point is not. Crisis to Care, the countywide partnership, says that every day in Buffalo “approximately 18 calls to 911 are coded as behavioral health-related,” BTPM reported.
Law Enforcement Digest, citing The Buffalo News, reported this week that the team, created in 2020, lost its clinical partner earlier this year when the department ended its relationship with Endeavor Health. Since April, officers have worked without that clinical support. The Erie County Department of Mental Health has taken over the partnership and is choosing a new provider through a request for proposals.
What the team does now, and what it does not
Department of Mental Health Director Sarah Bonk helped design the original model while she worked at Endeavor Health, Law Enforcement Digest reported, citing The Buffalo News. She said it fell short in moving beyond basic community service links and assessments toward stronger treatment plans, and that dispatch and communication between clinicians and law enforcement were poorly coordinated. She said the county will provide funding, select the provider and help track outcomes, and that she hopes the city can fund the program if the pilot succeeds and the model can be used elsewhere in the county.
Buffalo police data show that 1% of the team’s responses have ended in arrests, according to the same account. Officer Katelynn Bolden said the goal is always to avoid jail, though arrests occur when someone is seriously hurt or property is significantly damaged. Officers may take people to Erie County Medical Center under a state law that allows police discretion when they fear someone may harm themselves or others, to a diversion center, or to the ECMC Help Center for assessment.
Capt. Sharese Saleh said incarceration and hospitalization do not always fit the need, Law Enforcement Digest reported.
The unit currently works only from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., a limit Common Council members have questioned. Bonk said the first goal is to do the daytime shift successfully, then consider a second shift, and that building toward 24/7 coverage is possible.

A county system still finding its next stop
The pilot sits inside a larger county effort. In December 2025, the Crisis to Care Collaborative released a 55-page analysis of how emergency call centers, police, EMS and health providers in Erie County handle mental health emergencies. Dr. Mike Hogan, the former commissioner of the New York State Office of Mental Health and the report’s lead author, said the review covered datasets involving more than one million annual 911 calls, interviews with at least 50 stakeholders, and community listening sessions, according to a Crisis to Care release.
“I don’t know of such an in-depth review of a county’s behavioral health emergency response system conducted anywhere else in New York State,” Hogan said.
“This report shows we can improve how emergency calls are handled, expand the use of specialized response teams, and give first responders better options for getting people in crisis to immediate care,” said Lisa Chimera, Erie County’s deputy county executive and a member of the collaborative’s leadership committee.
Sheriff John Garcia struck a similar note. “This report marks a critical first step in recognizing the cracks we need to fill when it comes to mental health response,” he said. “While we do our best to train dispatchers and deputies to appropriately handle such calls, there is no doubt that a holistic approach to addressing crises is necessary.”
Cheektowaga Police Chief Brian Coons said police are often the only available responders, “even though we’re not always the ideal option for a mental health crisis.” He pointed to his department’s Behavioral Health Team, which pairs a clinician with a specially trained officer, and said the report “gives us new data to support expanding this team so we can respond to more 911 calls involving behavioral health emergencies.”

What people in crisis say they need
The collaborative also heard from residents. Cassidy Baron described a family member who sought help while having thoughts of suicide and then found police at the door.
“I’m grateful for the lifesaving role police can play,” Baron said in the December release. “But when someone you love is already overwhelmed by shame, heartbreak, and feeling completely misunderstood—so much so that they’re thinking about ending their life—seeing law enforcement at the door isn’t comforting. It feels like punishment, and it deepens the despair they’re already fighting.”
On the care side, BestSelf’s vice president of clinic services and care coordination, Paige Hawkins, told Thursday’s panel that the agency’s BestResponse intensive crisis stabilization center — which the December report said was scheduled to open on Niagara Street in January 2026 — is using that feedback from the start, including by serving children and their families.
“We have a place for family support. So the child may come in, with the family members, as the one who is the identified individual needing our care at that time. But then, throughout the stabilization process, we end up treating the family as a whole, and that care and that level of care and the time that we have to work with an individual and family separates our intensive center from what we’ve seen in the community so far,” Hawkins said, according to BTPM.
Sharon Gandarilla-Javier, an assistant professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, warned that municipalities often run pilots and then stop funding them instead of growing the teams or making them permanent, Law Enforcement Digest reported, citing The Buffalo News.
The $500,000 is a one-year test. Bonk’s own hope, as reported, is that the city picks up the cost if the numbers justify it, and that the model can be copied in other Erie County municipalities that now either contract for a clinician or send officers alone. The unanswered question, after Thursday’s panel and the News’s reporting, is whether the county and the city will treat this as a temporary patch or as the first shift of a 24-hour co-response system.
Featured photo: The Buffalo Police Department’s District B station on Main Street at East Tupper Street, April 2020. Photo by Andre Carrotflower via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped.
Sources: Buffalo Toronto Public Media, Emyle Watkins, Nov. 13, 2026; Law Enforcement Digest, Nov. 11, 2026, citing The Buffalo News; Crisis to Care Collaborative, Dec. 16, 2025.


















Leave a Reply