Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

·

DOE touts West Valley cleanup progress, but the study behind its biggest decision still hasn’t been released

The Energy Department is highlighting demolition and a rebuilt spillway at the West Valley nuclear site, but the draft study it projected for late 2025, which underpins a Phase 2 cleanup decision once targeted for Jan. 1, 2027, has still not been published.

Department of Energy and contractor officials in safety vests pose outside a fenced area at the West Valley Demonstration Project

By Hannah Lindqvist

WEST VALLEY — The federal government has spent much of October talking up its progress at the West Valley nuclear site in northern Cattaraugus County. The Energy Department’s top cleanup official toured the property. A rebuilt dam spillway got a write-up. Crews keep tearing down buildings that once handled spent nuclear fuel.

But the study that is supposed to settle the site’s hardest question has still not been released. That question is whether buried tanks, waste disposal areas and contaminated ground are dug up and shipped away, or left in place and watched for generations.

In a February 2024 presentation on the study, the U.S. Department of Energy listed a “Phase 2 decision on January 1, 2027” as a primary goal. Its timeline projected a draft Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement around October or November 2025, public comments around April 2026, a final version around November 2026 and a Record of Decision around January 2027.

As of early Tuesday, the department’s SEIS documents page still says the draft and final documents “will be available for downloading and browsing when they are published.” No draft is posted there. The decision target is about nine weeks away.

What Phase 2 would decide

The West Valley Demonstration Project sits on the state-owned Western New York Nuclear Service Center, about 35 miles south of Buffalo. In an Oct. 13 article, DOE’s Office of Environmental Management called it the site of “the only commercial used nuclear fuel reprocessing plant” to have operated in the United States.

The cleanup is being done in phases. According to DOE’s description of the study, Phase 2 covers the Waste Tank Farm, the NRC-Licensed Disposal Area, the State-Licensed Disposal Area, the non-source area of the North Plateau groundwater plume, a debris landfill, the so-called Cesium Prong, stream sediments and the rest of the roughly 3,300-acre center. DOE and the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) are preparing the study together. They are weighing a no-action option, closing the whole site in place, removing everything, and mixes of those.

The stakes are about water. The site drains through Buttermilk Creek and Cattaraugus Creek toward Lake Erie. Groups such as the Coalition on West Valley Nuclear Wastes, which holds a seat on the site’s Citizen Task Force, have long argued for full removal.

Progress the department is pointing to

On the Oct. 13 visit, Environmental Management Assistant Secretary Tim Walsh was photographed with officials in front of what DOE described as “56 high-level waste casks on the site’s temporary storage pad.” Those casks hold the glassified waste from the reprocessing era. That waste has no permanent federal destination.

“Our cleanup work in New York is focused on responsibly addressing legacy conditions and steadily reducing long-term risk for the community and future generations,” Walsh said in the department’s release. “Here at West Valley, my team is delivering results by improving efficiency through innovation, prioritization and disciplined cost and schedule management — without compromising safety or effectiveness.”

Bryan Bower, director of the West Valley Demonstration Project, said that because it is “the only commercial used nuclear fuel reprocessing plant to have operated in the United States, seeing the work firsthand is important to understanding the progress being made at the site and how it supports EM’s mission and overall cleanup strategy.”

The department said the Main Plant Process Building was demolished in 2025, and that work to take down the Fuel Receiving and Storage Facility is under way. Contractor slides from the Aug. 26 quarterly public meeting show crews removing that building’s steel and overhead crane. They also show soil sampling for a retention wall needed for excavation, and planning to remove 13 pumps from the tank farm.

DOE also said NYSERDA “has contributed more than $300 million toward the cleanup” under the West Valley Demonstration Project Act of 1980. The department says New York is the only state that shares in the cost of high-level waste cleanup.

A spillway, and a trout stream

In an Oct. 20 article, DOE said it had rebuilt the auxiliary spillway at Lake 1 with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Buffalo District. The new spillway is 246 feet of reinforced concrete and replaces a turf channel. The department said the old design raised concerns about “sediment reaching a protected trout stream at the foot of the spillway that ultimately connects to Lake Erie.”

“While the demand for large volumes of water for used fuel reprocessing operations has ceased, the lake-and-dam system remains vital for site management and continued operation,” said Anthony Lechanski, an Environmental Management federal project director. “The lakes, and specifically the spillway improvement project, now primarily serve to manage water, ensuring proper conveyance to prevent flooding.”

The site has also been building ties with local emergency crews. “We understand the importance and benefit of partnering with outside agencies that have additional experience, expertise and technology,” Jennifer Dundas, assistant director of West Valley’s Office of Technical Services, told the Springville Journal this month.

A fault on Wednesday’s agenda

The schedule question could come up Wednesday night. The West Valley Citizen Task Force, a 19-member advisory group that has met since 1997, meets from 6:30 to 8 p.m. at the Ashford Office Complex, 9030 Route 219, and on Zoom.

The agenda includes a project update from the West Valley Cleanup Alliance, the DOE contractor. It also lists a 7 p.m. talk titled “A Partially Characterized Fault near Springville, NY,” by Ray Vaughan, a Hamburg environmental scientist who sits on the task force. Members will also hear about Rep. Nick Langworthy’s new representative to the group and review the 2027 meeting schedule. The next quarterly public meeting is tentatively set for Nov. 18.

Whether the site can safely keep waste in place over long periods depends partly on how the ground behaves, including erosion and geology. That is why a fault discussion near a pending close-in-place decision is likely to draw attention.

Slides from the Oct. 28 meeting, including the October project update for the West Valley Demonstration Project and Vaughan’s presentation on the fault, are now posted on the task force’s 2026 meeting materials page, according to Heike Jacob, a senior planner with Highland Planning in Buffalo who facilitates the Citizen Task Force.

The Chronicle had asked whether task force members, including Vaughan, would discuss the meeting. Jacob said the group does not make individual members available to reporters. “The CTF operates by consensus, and it is the practice of the CTF that individual CTF members cannot represent the CTF in discussions with the press, etc.,” Jacob said in an email to The Buffalo Chronicle. “As such, we don’t direct the media to individual CTF members.” She said questions for the group can be sent to her.

Questions outstanding

The department first announced the study in a 2018 Federal Register notice, more than eight years ago. The department’s own public materials reviewed by The Chronicle do not give a new date for the draft study or the Phase 2 decision.

What DOE and NYSERDA say

DOE’s Office of Environmental Management and NYSERDA answered in a joint statement provided by Joseph Pillittere, director of communications and external affairs for the West Valley Cleanup Alliance, the DOE contractor. The statement did not give a date for the draft study or the Phase 2 decision, and it did not directly address the January 2027 goal. It said the draft depends on a technical analysis that the agencies expect to reach a key milestone by the end of 2027.

“Development of the Draft SEIS requires substantial completion of the probabilistic performance assessment (PPA), and the agencies are on track to reach that milestone by the end of 2027,” the agencies said in the statement, provided in an email to The Buffalo Chronicle. “At that point, the PPA will provide an important technical basis for defining and evaluating alternatives and for supporting identification of a preferred alternative. As those alternatives are refined, the agencies expect to have a clearer understanding of the remaining work and the time needed to complete the Draft SEIS.”

The agencies said the Phase 2 decisions “could involve billions of dollars in expenditures,” and that the analyses consider “the effects of erosion and extreme weather over thousands of years.” “To make sound decisions, the agencies need a technically robust SEIS that identifies the impacts of the alternatives, explains the basis for comparing them, and describes the uncertainties in the analyses and their implications for decision-making,” the statement said.

“DOE and NYSERDA remain committed to a six-month public comment period on the Draft SEIS before completion of the Final SEIS and the subsequent Phase 2 decision and will continue to provide stakeholders with updates as the work progresses,” the agencies said. Study documents are posted on DOE’s SEIS documents page.

Featured photo: U.S. Department of Energy Office of Environmental Management leaders and site officials at the West Valley Demonstration Project in October 2026. Photo by the U.S. Department of Energy (public domain).

Updated November 3, 2026: This story was updated to include comment from the facilitator of the West Valley Citizen Task Force and a link to materials from the task force’s Oct. 28 meeting.

Updated November 9, 2026: This story was updated to include comment from the U.S. Department of Energy and NYSERDA.

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements