Buffalo · Western New York

An independent digital newspaper covering Buffalo, Western New York, Albany, Washington and the border region.

The Buffalo Chronicle

Always be fair. When you can, be kind.

The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Sign up free →

· · · ·

Senate Budget chair Ron Johnson’s defense blueprint heads into the lame duck as the deficit nears $2 trillion

Sen. Ron Johnson’s fiscal 2027 budget resolution, which would make room for $60 billion more for the military through reconciliation, has stalled since August. It returns after the election as Treasury reports a $1.992 trillion deficit.

Official portrait of Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee

By Thomas Whitaker

WASHINGTON — The Senate Budget Committee’s plan for a third Republican reconciliation bill has been sitting on the Senate calendar since Aug. 7. When lawmakers come back after the Nov. 3 election, its sponsor, Budget Chairman Ron Johnson (R-Wis.), will be pressing for it against a backdrop of new federal numbers showing the government ran a deficit of nearly $2 trillion in the budget year that ended Sept. 30.

Johnson took over the committee in July after the death of Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.). On Aug. 7 he introduced S. Con. Res. 38, the fiscal 2027 budget resolution, which is the first step toward a bill that could pass the Senate with a simple majority. Senate Republicans dropped a planned vote on it that night. They have not brought it back up.

The resolution is built around President Donald Trump’s request for more money for the military. Johnson’s office said in a statement that it “provides the blueprint to unlock the reconciliation process that will deliver critical election integrity improvements and the Trump Administration’s national security supplemental request.”

What the Senate blueprint would do

The text instructs 11 Senate committees to write legislation. The Armed Services Committee could add up to $60 billion to deficits over 10 years. The Intelligence Committee gets $13 billion and the Agriculture Committee $12 billion. The Homeland Security, Judiciary and Rules committees could each add up to $20 billion, and five other committees $1 billion apiece. The instructions add up to $150 billion with no offsetting cuts required. The resolution set a Sept. 11 deadline for committees to submit their pieces, which passed with no Senate vote on the resolution.

Johnson told reporters the $150 billion figure was larger than the bill would actually be, according to Roll Call, and was meant to give committees room to work. He put the intended package at about $105 billion, including $20 billion for voter identification measures, $10 billion more than the House plan.

The House adopted its own blueprint, H. Con. Res. 113, in July. It carries the same $60 billion for defense, $13 billion for intelligence and $12 billion in farm aid, but instructs only four House committees. The two chambers would have to adopt the same resolution before a reconciliation bill could move.

The $60 billion falls well short of what the administration asked for. The Office of Management and Budget requested $350 billion in reconciliation money for the Defense Department for fiscal 2027, as part of a $1.5 trillion defense budget, according to an August analysis by the Center for Strategic and International Studies. OMB documents said the approach would “[decouple] funding for Republican priorities from Democrat waste.” The White House also sent Congress an $87.6 billion supplemental request in June, mostly tied to the war with Iran.

In his August statement, Johnson blamed Democrats for the impasse that pushed Republicans toward reconciliation.

“When we have the finest among us – the men and women in our armed services – in harm’s way, it is beyond unfortunate that providing support for their efforts and protection has turned into a partisan issue,” Johnson said. “In less partisan times, the requested appropriation supplemental for these priorities would have sailed through Congress with bipartisan support. Instead, because of Democrat obstructionism, we are having to resort to the budget reconciliation process.”

Why the vote was called off

Republicans scrapped the Aug. 7 procedural vote after a late-night meeting in the office of Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) and a phone call with Trump, Roll Call reported. Trump had urged senators for weeks not to leave for the August recess without progress on the package. Johnson said the president agreed to give the effort more time.

“There was a concern whether or not we could actually pass the budget resolution tonight,” Johnson told reporters, according to Roll Call. “Then we had a discussion with the president. He agrees. Don’t take the vote tonight, and just work diligently through August and September to do an actually … better reconciliation bill.”

The package has divided Republicans. Defense hawks want far more than $60 billion for the Pentagon, while budget hawks object to spending without offsetting cuts, and some senators oppose the voter ID provisions, according to the CSIS analysis.

Those divisions remain heading into the lame-duck session. Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio) told reporters this month, “We will do a reconciliation bill. One way or the other, we will,” The Washington Sun reported on Oct. 22. Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.), a member of GOP leadership, was more cautious. “Those things take a lot of time,” she said. “We didn’t have the votes … for a reconciliation package earlier.”

Government funding runs out on Dec. 11, and Republican leaders have also discussed using a reconciliation bill to raise the debt limit, the Sun reported.

A $1.99 trillion deficit

The fight over the blueprint will play out against the government’s final books for fiscal 2026. The Treasury Department’s Monthly Treasury Statement for September put the deficit at $1.992 trillion, up from $1.775 trillion the year before. Spending rose to $7.396 trillion. Revenue also hit a record, $5.403 trillion.

The Congressional Budget Office’s monthly budget review found that revenue rose $169 billion, or 3 percent, while outlays rose $386 billion, or 6 percent. Net interest on the debt rose $115 billion, or 11 percent, which accounted for more than half of the increase in the deficit. Defense spending rose $48 billion. Customs receipts fell after the government refunded about $130 billion in tariffs that the Supreme Court ruled in February had been imposed without authority under an emergency-powers law, CBO said.

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has argued the country can grow its way out of its debt. In an August interview with CNBC, he said the odds were “very good” that the deficit had already peaked, and said, “Our message to our allies, our trading partners, is that global growth is the way to take care of this mountain of debt.”

Johnson has framed the debt as a moral issue. “It’s wrong. It’s immoral. It’s got to stop,” he said in September on the John Solomon Reports podcast, according to Just the News. He has long proposed holding federal spending to about 18 percent of the economy, roughly what the government has collected in revenue on average. “People like me are vastly outnumbered,” he said.

Democrats point to the tax law

The committee’s top Democrat, Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.), blames last year’s tax and spending law. In September he released a CBO analysis he requested finding that if interest rates ran 1 percentage point above the agency’s baseline, federal debt would reach 222 percent of the economy by 2056, compared with 175 percent under the baseline.

“This analysis from the Congressional Budget Office should be a five-alarm fire for every Senator and House member,” Merkley said. “We can start getting our debt under control by reversing the tax giveaways to the ultrawealthy that Republicans made permanent last year.”

Republicans have defended the 2025 law. Graham, in a July 2 statement marking its first anniversary, said the law delivered the largest tax cut for the working and middle class. The year’s spending growth was also broad: outlays for Social Security rose $86 billion and Medicare $77 billion, according to an American Action Forum summary of CBO’s figures.

On the House side, Budget Chairman Jodey Arrington (R-Texas) has called for a bipartisan fiscal commission. At a Sept. 21 field hearing in Dallas, he said, “Both parties have to accept and own their fair share of responsibility and stop blaming each other.” He added, “No one party will unilaterally address the structural deficit that is driving our national debt.”

Johnson has said he intends to serve as chairman “for the remainder of the year.” Committee assignments for the next Congress will be set after the election.

The Buffalo Chronicle has asked the Senate Budget Committee’s majority and minority press offices, the House Budget Committee and the White House Office of Management and Budget for comment on the outlook for the budget resolution and the deficit.

Photo: Sen. Ron Johnson’s official portrait. United States Senate Photographic Studio, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

Have a tip or a correction? Email editor@buffalochronicle.com or send a tip. Read our standards.

Advertisements

Free newsletter

Get The Morning Briefing

Our reporting, in your inbox. Free.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Advertisements