BY E.J. McMAHON
Since the late 1960s, New York’s primary export to the rest of the nation has been people, as reflected in federal data tracking population flows within and between states.
The Empire State has lost a net 1,585,770 residents to the rest of the country since 2010, the largest outflow of any state in both absolute terms and as a percentage of 2010 base population, according to the latest U.S. Census Bureau estimates. This does not include the migratory flows reportedly touched off by the pandemic in the past year; it remains to be seen how many of those moves were temporary and how many were permanent.
In the years leading up to the pandemic, where were outbound New Yorkers headed? What were their average household income levels once they settled in their new home states?
Some answers can be gleaned from the Census Bureau’s primary source of migration data: the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), which can track the movement of tax filers based on the residence listed on their tax forms. The IRS has compiled that information for all states in pairs of years, starting in 2011-12, and the latest data, for 2018-19, were released this week.
Updating our January 2020 report focused on the seven-year period from 2011-18, the Empire Center has mapped 2018-19 interstate movements of New Yorkers on a statewide, regional and county level, as shown below (with average incomes as reported for returns filed in 2019).
Favored landing spots
For a second consecutive year, the leading destination state for outbound New Yorkers was New Jersey, which attracted 67,131 former Empire State residents. Second most popular was Florida, to which 59,881 New Yorkers moved.
Subtracting outflows from inflows, Florida topped all states as the net destination of New Yorkers, with a net inflow of 32,168 Empire State residents—or 20.9 percent of New York’s net outflow in 2018-19. Just behind Florida was New Jersey, which accounted for 20.2 percent of New York’s net outflow.
Rounding out the top 10 net destinations for New Yorkers in 2018-19 were North Carolina (7.9 percent), Pennsylvania (7.1 percent), Connecticut (6.4 percent), California (4.9 percent), Texas (4.5 percent), Georgia (4.4 percent), South Carolina (3.7 percent) and Virginia (2.9 percent). These 10 states collectively account for 83 percent of New York’s net out-migration as measured by the 2018-19 IRS data.
When migration patterns from New York are examined at the regional and county level, some different patterns emerge. For example, while Florida was the leading net destination for seven upstate regions and Long Island, neighboring Connecticut was the top destination for migrating Westchester County residents, and New Jersey was the top destination for out-migrants from New York City.
Rising incomes headed south
One of the more striking trends in the latest data was the continuing increase in the incomes of New Yorkers moving to Florida. In 2018-19, the average incomes of Florida-bound New York out-migrants rose to $135,000, up from $120,000 the previous year. As shown below, this continues a trend that dates back to the 2011-12, the first year in the current IRS Migration Data series.
Only two states, Utah ($140,649) and Wyoming ($187,734), drew New Yorkers with higher average incomes—but together accounted for barely 0.2 percent of New York’s net migration outflow. In contrast to New Jersey and Connecticut, whose smaller number of taxpayer migrants to New York State made six-figures incomes from their New York addresses, the average Florida migrant to New York between 2018 and 2019 reported incomes averaging $72,492.
Keeping in mind that the tax returns filed in each year reflect income reported for the previous calendar year—i.e., returns filed in 2018 are based on incomes for 2017—the IRS migration data for New York proceed from the following top-level figures:
- 8,081,228 individual income tax returns were filed from New York State addresses in 2018. Out of that group, 228,099 primary taxpayers—i.e., the name listed first on 1040 Forms—filed returns from a different state in 2019. Those 228,099 taxpayers represented a total of 386,910 people, including spouses and dependents. This was the interstate outflow of taxpayers.
- 154,262 primary taxpayers who filed from other states in 2018, reflecting a total of 232,864 people including spouses and dependents, filed from New York State addresses in 2019. This was the interstate inflow of taxpayers.
- Another 254,051 returns were filed from New York State addresses in both years, but from different counties.
The difference between the outflow and inflow is net migration, which in New York’s case was a net outflow of 154,046 people.
The IRS data also shows the number of interstate and intrastate moves on the county level. The total adjusted gross incomes (before deductions) for all taxpayers are reported for both years; in the data shown in our map, the average incomes are for 2019, the year following the move.
The Census Bureau estimate of net out migration for 2018-19 was larger, at 183,857. because it was for a different period (the 12 months ending July 1) and because it takes account of other factors, such as cases in which spouses file a joint return in one year and two single returns in another, and in which people claimed as dependents in one year file their own returns as non-dependents in another.
EJ McMahon is the founder of the Empire Center for Public Policy.
Be the first to comment